Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sat 25th Aug 2012 19:40 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 532515
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[6]: Comment by MOS6510
by Doc Pain on Mon 27th Aug 2012 03:16
in reply to "RE[5]: Comment by MOS6510"
"Earth and the universe did fine for billions of years without any money.
And yet, money emerged. The earth and the universe obviously had a need for money. "
No. Just several people had a need for money. One may speculate that some amount of them could be categorized as parasites, as today there's a significant share of people benefiting from the existence of money without creating any value or contributing to mankind, draining energy from the whole system.
RE[7]: Comment by MOS6510
by kwan_e on Mon 27th Aug 2012 03:47
in reply to "RE[6]: Comment by MOS6510"
"[q]Earth and the universe did fine for billions of years without any money.
And yet, money emerged. The earth and the universe obviously had a need for money. "
No. Just several people had a need for money. [/q]
Are people not part of the Earth and the universe?
* Hint: just because the universe has no need for money doesn't mean it shouldn't exist. The universe has no need for life either. You can't argue about the need for properties which are emergent.
** This is not to say that money is perfect. I would say money needs to be subject to conservation laws like the rest of physical and biological laws. None of this "Company A is really worth $600 billion because the total of its shares at the current share price is worth $600 billion" nonsense.





Member since:
2007-02-18
There still are costs. In fact, lots of animals pay with sex or food or building materials.
Anthills and beehives go bust all the time. Of course, it now turns out that Colony Collapse Disorder is caused by Bayer's insecticide, but entymologists would tell you that a great number of beehives die out every year normally.
Except that's precisely how flightless birds came about.
If the lost tourist had the right amount of money in the right currency then they would be able to bribe the lion.
Actually, the only dolphins that have a "fun time" are those you see at those water parks (whatever name it is). How do you know they are having "fun"? They're having "fun" to get the continued supply of fish. Out in the wild, it's a constant battle against starvation and murder.
Humans are apes.
Which goes back to the question about the currency in use.
And yet, money emerged. The earth and the universe obviously had a need for money.