Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 5th Sep 2012 23:28 UTC, submitted by Hiev
Google "I was recently testing some of the keywords and positions for our help-desk app and it suddenly occurred to me that 80% of the page were not actually the search results. Check this out." He has a very good point. Google has work to do here.
Thread beginning with comment 534005
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Everyone needs money
by ramasubbu_sk on Thu 6th Sep 2012 00:00 UTC
ramasubbu_sk
Member since:
2007-04-05

I agree - I see too many sites like any other adware sites.

Afterall they need money - they running the search service to show ads & make money. They are not running for free service.

With competition from Bing,Yahoo,...etc I think, the margin in ads are going down to make that up they are now showing more ads.

It would be great to see the comparison between Bing & Google for couple similar results.

http://www.bing.com/search?q=saas+help+desk

Reply Score: 1

RE: Everyone needs money
by galvanash on Thu 6th Sep 2012 06:16 in reply to "Everyone needs money"
galvanash Member since:
2006-01-25

Afterall they need money - they running the search service to show ads & make money. They are not running for free service.


Look carefully at the images in the original article again...

I did the math. If you normalize to correct for the shady things the guy did ( the two images are of two different searches) the actual area used by advertising has dropped from the old layout to the new one (by approximately 3%).

He is right that the search results area is smaller, but the difference is 14% - not 35% as is implied in the article. But it has not been at the expense of showing more advertising - it is primarily the utility sidebar that has infringed on the search results area.

However, the biggest difference between the old layout and the new one is simply whitespace. The relative area consumed by wasted horizontal whitespace (using his images) has dropped by 30%.

Im not defending Google at all btw. If I thought the facts backed this guy up I would be the first to agree with him. But his implied conclusion is that Google is sacrificing search result area to show more ads - that is simply 100% categorically false.

Some people don't like the utility sidebar, and that is an honest gripe - but that isn't advertising...

Reply Parent Score: 11