Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sun 11th Nov 2012 15:49 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 542080
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[4]: Just how bad it has become? What?
by kaiwai on Mon 12th Nov 2012 13:38
in reply to "RE[3]: Just how bad it has become? What?"
I don't know what you read but the review was over two parts (Part 1: http://kawaiigardiner.com/2012/11/07/product-review-lenovo-thinkcen... link to Part 2 at the bottom) and I clearly state the scope of the review in the section called 'Background'. If it isn't 'up to standard' then great but how about not linking to crappy articles rehashing the same crappy arguments as the linked article has done. btw, my criticism of the article in more depth I did has a reply to another person in this thread.
Regarding the seat, it is very comfortable 




Member since:
2006-02-15
I don't know Thom's reasons for not linking to your reviews, but I did just check them out. I do not wish to make you feel bad or anything, but from a journalistic standpoint you're not really reviewing anything there, it reads more like a "How I spent my day" - kind of a thing. I mean, you're installing a custom software package on the systems so you're not really reviewing the systems as they come from the manufacturers, and you're not really reviewing the things from a hardware point of view, either. It comes off as if you didn't really have a well-defined goal in mind with what you were writing about, and you had no specific idea of what it is that you wish to convey to the readers.
I may come off as a dick right now, but that is not my meaning and I do not wish to offend you. I'm not a professional journalist myself, either, and I have no literature - related credentials of any sort to back up my opinions or feelings, so pay attention to what I say only as much as you feel like. That said, your reviews weren't unpleasant to read, per se, but maybe next time define for yourself more clearly what it actually is you wish to say?
PS. Doesn't your back start to ache after sitting for several hours on such a chair? It looks like it'd be very comfortable to watch movies in or read something, but for doing something on a computer you have to lean forward all the time while the cushioning itself is pulling you back.