To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Take a look at the main site as is though. Flat, rectangular buttons and the only exceptions are the "search" and "RSS" buttons with just a bare hint of a bevel. Apart from that, we have the comment box buttons which are themed by the OS/browser. Everything else is flat and fairly simple, and very text-oriented.
The new design just seems to be an evolution of that.
Maybe their opinion might be more to do with the monochromatic look, not the actual flatness? Similar to how people mistake contrast for sharpness in photographs, to some extent. It might not be the actual flatness that's bothering them, but the nondescript nature of the layout. Personally don't see it as a bad thing, but I assume some people would like more "pop" in their web pages. Just an assumption, though.
Strange that I prefer the light grey backdrop to the black, considering I often work with dark terminals and GTKs. The light theme's got a nice smoothness about it, without the jarring contrast ratio of the dark theme. Heck, I think I'll go make a new Xdefaults colorscheme around that light grey and green, just for kicks.





Member since:
2005-07-06
I second some of edwdig's concerns. The first thing that jumped out at me (and I do remember Thom stating that the site might not ship looking like this) is that there is a complete lack of OSNews branding. To me, there is no "feeling" of OSNews in the site design, sans green. Even OSNews at the top of the page is simply text. The other thing is, as edwdig pointed out, the flat design. I too feel like there is this huge pendulum swing toward flat design and it is being overdone. Sure, the design does not have to jump out at you like a webpage from 1995, but using shadows, rounded corners and bevels can be very simple and pleasing.