To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Great that you picked up on this - this is a feature, not a bug
. I've often noticed that some people tend to focus on who posted a comment, instead of the actual content of a comment. As such, I wanted to make it less clear WHO posted a comment, so that the CONTENT of a comment gains prominence. " People have differing tastes. I personally would call this a mis-feature as I find the availability of graphical avatars making it much quicker for the eye to latch on and discern where one comment starts and another ends and whose comments I'd like to view first. It's one of the things I hate about e.g. Slashdot: I know several people who tend to make insightful, read-worthy comments, but without such a quick way of finding those aforementioned comments I have to trudge through them all in the hopes of finding those gems. It totally discourages me from participating and results in me skipping 99% of all the comments.
Great that you picked up on this - this is a feature, not a bug
. I've often noticed that some people tend to focus on who posted a comment, instead of the actual content of a comment. As such, I wanted to make it less clear WHO posted a comment, so that the CONTENT of a comment gains prominence. " I love the fact that people's names and identities are tied to their comments. It makes it feel like a conversation with real people, rather than an anonymous horde. I second the thought that this is a "mis"-feature.
Distinction between individual comments is preferable, and the origin of the comment should be easily identifiable. I mean, lets face it: Not all comments are equal. While I'm not sure I'd go so far as to say that there are those who always post garbage comments I'd want to skip, there are those that frequently post insightful, well-informed comments, and it would be nice if it were easier to pick their comments out. Heck, being able to color-code the people you pick as one of your favorites would be useful.
This is already possible using the "friends and fans" feature. If someone is a "fan" of yours, their comment header shows up in yellow. If you become a "fan" of the same person, your relationship changes to "friends" and their header is now a light green.
It would be great if this particular feature survives the change.
. I've often noticed that some people tend to focus on who posted a comment, instead of the actual content of a comment. As such, I wanted to make it less clear WHO posted a comment, so that the CONTENT of a comment gains prominence. On the other hand, I use the name as a filter to decide if a comment is worth my time or not. When I read two annoying comments from some hyperactive fanboy who's arguing for the sake of arguing despite overwhelming evidence, then his next posts in that discussion are likely to be annoying as well - and usually they start dominating the whole comment section which ruins other discussions.
It might be an interesting experiment to fold all of someone's posts in a topic when that person has two down-voted posts in that same topic (or perhaps even for x posts with score 1 where x > 10, which means he's spamming the place with non-upvoted comments). Other topics would be unaffected.
Edited 2012-12-27 01:40 UTC





Member since:
2005-06-29
Great that you picked up on this - this is a feature, not a bug