To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Indeed, some people. Likely most people won't encounter such situations. For this rare or unlikely event you need to buy an extra battery (money), have/keep it charged (hassle) and take it along (hassle).
Why not buy a general purpose mobile charging device? It would work with any gadget, provide more power and you don't have to swap batteries. If the phone breaks you wouldn't be left with a battery that doesn't fit the new model phone.
Depends, sometimes a device can be made with a low quality battery that conveniently dies outside out of warranty, and you either like the device and don't want to upgrade it, and/or you can't afford it to replace it.
I've been in that situation at least once before, and if my current phone (HTC Desire Z) were to die, I would be in that situation once more, as I don't feel that any new phone currently available would make me want to spend a few hundred [insert local currency units] when I can get a new battery for $10-20 off eBay from China for a phone that I am very fond of.
That's a very valid point.
But you'd need to know in advance if you're going to like the phone so much and apart from the battery there are more weak points that can break like hardware buttons, the screen, the casing, components on the inside, USB/charging connector, the SD card slot.
I guess it's a personal evaluation of the risks vs benefits/disadvantages mixed with feelings and experience.
Most likely by the time the phone is out of warranty and stuff breaks, which can take a long time if handled with care, better and improved models are around that valid an upgrade to them.
There are still many iPhone 3GS's around that are years old and still work. If they break down the iPhone 5 is a huge upgrade.





Member since:
2011-05-12
I don't understand why people want a removable battery. By the time it wears out the phone will be a few generations old and obsoleted.
My wife and I have owned a number of mobile phones with removable batteries, so have people at work. The only phones for which I ever ordered a new battery were a few BlackBerries.
The battery of my iPhone 3G (no S) still works fine. hell, even my Nokia E90 still holds a charge all day.
Personally I'd give up a removable battery for any advantages that would bear.