Linked by Thom Holwerda on Tue 15th Jan 2013 23:28 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 548937
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE: Will give me something to play with
by StephenBeDoper on Wed 16th Jan 2013 02:19
in reply to "Will give me something to play with"
The only thing I somewhat like about BB OS is that it takes some UI cues from WebOS - but even that was done in a much inferior way (I still love the WebOS card metaphor and their implementation of it).
Same experience here. I picked one up when they reached the CAD $140 mark a few months back - I'd used one when they were first released and I'm also using a Pre2, so I figured I'd get some use out of it just because of the UI being familiar/comfortable.
But in practice, I've found that it's *just* different enough to cause an "uncanny valley" effect - E.g. webOS reacts to much shorter swipes from the top/bottom than PlaybookOS does (though it could just be perception, due to the different screen sizes). That (IME) makes the UI feel less responsive. Though I will say that the bundled EMail client (once RIM finally released one) beats the pants off anything I've tried for Android tablets - seriously, when did auto/self-BCC become some kind of exotic/premium feature?
RE: Will give me something to play with
by matt4pack on Wed 16th Jan 2013 18:25
in reply to "Will give me something to play with"
RE[2]: Will give me something to play with
by umccullough on Wed 16th Jan 2013 21:53
in reply to "RE: Will give me something to play with"
A QNX based real-time OS based on gestures is pretty much the ultimate OS but it gets nothing but bashed on an OS website. Makes sense.
Yeah, except it's a closed system, which is a huge strike against it compared to Android (and hopefully WebOS).
I was even excited about the possibility of running android apps on my playbook (which I thought was a pretty awesome feature for RIM to include) - only to find they've really made it a PITA to do so now.
My opinion of BB OS is less about the technology, and more about the company that owns it - they're pretty pitiful these days.
RE[2]: Will give me something to play with
by dagw on Fri 18th Jan 2013 13:47
in reply to "RE: Will give me something to play with"
A QNX based real-time OS based on gestures is pretty much the ultimate OS
On paper and in theory I agree with you. They have a very interesting technological core. A QNX core with a choice of Qt or HTML 5 app development and the possibility to easily port Android apps with the Android run time.
That being said I kind of have to agree with Thom, it doesn't matter how awesome your technology is if you use it build a mediocre product. There are many many ways they can screw it up, and based on what I've seen and read chances are they probably will.
That being said I again, I really hope I'm wrong and that it will be awesome, and if that's the case I'll happily leave Android behind and my next phone will quite possibly be running BB10.
Edited 2013-01-18 13:50 UTC




Member since:
2006-01-26
A while back, I picked up a refurb Playbook to mess with - hoping eventually that someone would port Android to them.

Sadly, rooting it is a royal PITA given how they locked it down, and nobody seems to give a rat's ass about running Android on it. All the forums that revolve around this device (and other Blackberry devices) are rife with zealots who bash non-blackberry fans with a vengeance.
To this day, my Playbook sits here on the shelf collecting dust, until something more interesting comes along. The app store from RIM is pretty sorry - compared to my Touchpad running ICS (CM9), there's nothing of interest there for me.
The only thing I somewhat like about BB OS is that it takes some UI cues from WebOS - but even that was done in a much inferior way (I still love the WebOS card metaphor and their implementation of it).
At least it seems I'll be able to throw BB10 on the Playbook eventually - that will breathe new life into the device for a day or two