Linked by the_randymon on Fri 25th Jan 2013 09:21 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 550594
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[10]: Arch BSD, right?
by Soulbender on Sun 27th Jan 2013 08:15
in reply to "RE[9]: Arch BSD, right?"
The mobile operator that blocked the device is the only one allowed by law to unblock it, an operation to be done up to five days limit after being requested by the customer.
Does blocking equal locking in this case?
The Wikipedia link above gives similar scenarios for some European countries.
And NONE of them states that it is illegal to unlock your phone yourself or have someone do it for you, at least not for any of the European countries on the list.
RE[11]: Arch BSD, right?
by Laurence on Sun 27th Jan 2013 11:46
in reply to "RE[10]: Arch BSD, right?"
RE[11]: Arch BSD, right?
by moondevil on Sun 27th Jan 2013 16:22
in reply to "RE[10]: Arch BSD, right?"
And NONE of them states that it is illegal to unlock your phone yourself or have someone do it for you, at least not for any of the European countries on the list.
And yet the Portuguese law states otherwise.
http://www.anacom.pt/render.jsp?contentId=1027945
Google translate link,
http://translate.google.de/translate?sl=pt&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=en...
Article number 3. Only the entity that locked the phone is allowed to perform such operation.
For us locking means both SIM lock or any other form of device locking.
RE[10]: Arch BSD, right?
by Laurence on Sun 27th Jan 2013 11:45
in reply to "RE[9]: Arch BSD, right?"
Blocking isn't the same as locking.
A block is there to stop the phone being used if it's stolen. It's the telecoms equivalent of having your bank card blocked if you suspect someone has stolen your wallet. Thus it's in the best interest of the consumers to make blocking illegal (not that it does much to stop phone theft, but at least it's intentions are honourable).
Locking is just an arbitrary restriction to prevent a phone being used on different networks (or 'carriers' as Americans refer to it). There's no good reason why you'd want to make that illegal - aside to deliberately screw consumers over.
Thus unlocking phones is -as far as I'm aware- completely legal in the EU, but unblocking is illegal.





Member since:
2005-07-08
What can be found in 5 minute googling:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SIM_lock
In Portuguese:
http://www.computerworld.com.pt/2010/08/30/mais-facil-desbloquear-t...
The important part is this one:
Meaning you have the right to unblock the phone but only in certain scenarios as allowed by Portuguese law.
Or if you can read Spanish
http://www.liberar.ws/
Again the important part translated:
The Wikipedia link above gives similar scenarios for some European countries.
The main point is that you can not just unlocked when you feel like doing it, and additionally the operators themselves are the only ones allowed to do it.