Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 28th Feb 2013 15:42 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 553973
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[2]: Looks nice, one question....
by leech on Fri 1st Mar 2013 21:31
in reply to "RE: Looks nice, one question...."
Actually you really can't do anything with just the Kernel. Sure you could have busybox, which provides a shell, but you still have GNU libraries, which is why the hardcore people always refer to distributions as GNU/Linux, because you really can't do much with out the libraries/software outside of just the kernel. Granted Android doesn't use the GNU part all that much, which is why Android is just a different Linux based distribution, but very dissimilar to other Linux Distributions.
For the record, I use "Just Linux" with a shell all the time, and it's awesome.
RE[3]: Looks nice, one question....
by WereCatf on Fri 1st Mar 2013 21:55
in reply to "RE[2]: Looks nice, one question...."
Actually you really can't do anything with just the Kernel. Sure you could have busybox, which provides a shell
If you were using busybox on top of the kernel then busybox would be considered the userland, ergo it would qualify as a bare-bones OS. It wouldn't be just the kernel any longer, though.
but you still have GNU libraries, which is why the hardcore people always refer to distributions as GNU/Linux
No, there are replacements for most of these libraries. Considering your hypothetical busybox+Linux-kernel one could use e.g. uClibc instead of the standard libc, thereby avoiding the use of GNU-libraries. Using GNU is not a hard requirement for a Linux-distro.




Member since:
2010-03-08
I think the answers depend on what you call an operating system. Myself, I accept as an operating system any set of software which offers an interface between raw hardware, end users, and developers.
From this point of view, both the Linux kernel AND Linux distros qualify as OSs in their own right. Because one CAN operate a Linux kernel without any extra software through the standard shell if masochistic enough, whereas distros would be other OSs based on the Linux kernel.
Linux DEs taken separately, however, would not be OSs in their own right, since they require extra runtime support.
Edited 2013-02-28 23:08 UTC