Linked by Howard Fosdick on Tue 2nd Jul 2013 21:04 UTC
Editorial Like many of you, I've been watching the big changes in user interfaces over the past few years, trying to make sense of them all. Is there a common explanation for the controversies surrounding the Windows 8 UI and Unity? Where do GNOME 3, KDE, Cinnamon, and MATE fit in? This article offers one view.
Thread beginning with comment 566124
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
thesunnyk
Member since:
2010-05-21

I think Gnome 3 started as one idea and changed into another. I remember the initial ideas for Gnome 3 all heavily involved things like Zeitgeist. You would have a "history" and a "future" (TODOs), and everything would be set up for a GTD-style environment -- literally the entire desktop would be geared, as applications, for a getting things done workflow.

If you wanted to remember to write an email to someone later, you would literally begin writing that email and then shove it into a date or time when you needed to write it, and it would show up as a reminder at that time for writing. You could get a list of "tasks" you completed at the end of the day, etc. These were the kinds of ideas that were being thrown around: computing for professionals.

I actually agree with Microsoft on this: There's one OS for all form factors, whether it's phones or tablets or PCs. However, the focus needs to be different on each platform. A phone is like a swiss army knife -- you wouldn't choose to use one in a kitchen where a regular knife is available, but man is it convenient for camping.

I think everyone is searching for a natural abstraction which fits all three form factors. Everyone is taking it from differing perspectives, none of which are wrong, but they are all *attempts* at a solution, none are really cohesive yet. I don't doubt that we'll see a more cohesive environment emerge in the future.

I wrote a little about what the "natural" UI is for a free-as-in-speech OS here: http://blog.quaddmg.com/2013/6/14/ideas-for-gnome-4/

Reply Score: 2