Linked by Thom Holwerda on Tue 6th Aug 2013 11:35 UTC
Google Joshua Topolsky for The Verge:

But once I used the phone heavily, I started to come around to the Moto X in a way I hadn't expected. The additions to the software that Motorola has made are legitimately useful and really quite impressive. They add to the experience of Android without removing what is most vital in Google's software, unlike the competition, which seems intent on obscuring what's already a sophisticated and beautiful operating system. If Motorola ends up producing a Google Play Edition of this phone that retains the customizable hardware and software additions like Assist and Active Notifications - this could be as good an option as the S4 or One.

And the phone is nice. I mean, really nice to use. It's a reminder that the way something is built can be as important as what it's made of.

And Joseph Volpe at Engadget:

If I'm right in reading between the lines of Google's marketing speak, the Moto X was made in the image of the everyman. [...] The 4.7-inch screen size, the curvature of its back, the composite materials, its weight and front-face look were focus-tested for maximum inoffensiveness. The Moto X exudes no tech halo like the Galaxy S 4 or the HTC One because it is the sum of averages. Here's how I see it: You know those people who own iPhones, but don't know which model number they own and also refer to all Android phones as Droids? This phone is for them.

It seems like there's a consensus regarding the Moto X: it's average in almost every way, but for some reason, it still feels like a fantastic phone. It's not the best at any metric, but at the same time, nothing really sucks about it either. It's an interesting approach in the smartphone world, but since older and/or cheaper models (e.g. iPhone 4/4S, Galaxy SIII) are still selling really, really well, to the point where they harm margins, the Moto X might be on to something.

However, this makes the price tag that much weirder. It's $199 on contract, just like most other flagship phones. So, who is this for?

Thread beginning with comment 568957
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
for normal people!
by mmrezaie on Tue 6th Aug 2013 12:07 UTC
Member since:

You know I had iphone, and now I am using nexus 4. The thing I liked about HTC one was that it was not looking plasticky, and at the same time handled way better than iphone.

This time moto/google managed to do the right thing. Almost all people don't need very powerful processors, because they would just waste battery, but they need fastest gpu possible. Moto X from what I heard have the best balance possible, and also it has the best battery duration of them all. This is what matters. Oh, not to forget that it looks cool because its your custom choice.

The only thing that pisses me off is that they most likely won't upgrade the os. The point that they haven't released it with 4.3 is the point that they might continue their last mistakes again.

Reply Score: 2

RE: for normal people!
by Bill Shooter of Bul on Tue 6th Aug 2013 12:58 in reply to "for normal people!"
Bill Shooter of Bul Member since:

Any carrier released phone is going to have os upgrade problems, except apple for some reason. Luckily there is the Google edition that will be available for some unknown price at some unknown point. However... It won't have all of the cool features Moto baked in.

I'm kind of torn, and glad I don't have to make a decision anytime soon. I'd love for the google edition to be at the Nexus 4 price. That would make its successor very tempting in another year when my contract runs out. I think this is my last contract phone...

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE: for normal people!
by MechR on Tue 6th Aug 2013 13:49 in reply to "for normal people!"
MechR Member since:

The only thing that pisses me off is that they most likely won't upgrade the os. The point that they haven't released it with 4.3 is the point that they might continue their last mistakes again.

It released with 4.2 because 4.3 just came out the week before, and Google had publicly promised not to give Motorola early/special access to Android development.

Now the test will be how quickly/smoothly they push out the 4.3 update...

Reply Parent Score: 4