Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 9th Oct 2013 23:22 UTC
PDAs, Cellphones, Wireless

This is quite possibly one of the most beautiful articles you'll ever read about Nokia's demise. Five years ago, in 2008, a journalist wrote a letter to Nokia, on his own behalf, as a regular person (so not as a journalist). In it, he detailed how Nokia phones used to be easy to use by everyone. However, the Nokia E51 he was using now was a complete mess, insanely hard to use. He ended the letter with prescient words: "This will cause problems for Nokia".

The letter made its way to Nokia, and apparently caused waves inside the company, up to the highest levels. Company executives wanted to explain the company's strategy to him, and eventually, one executive even met up with him on a personal note. After first parroting the usual corporate speak, the executive eventually broke.

"I agree completely with everything that you wrote in your letter and what you have said now."

I was astounded.

"I completely agree with you and I want to apologise on behalf of Nokia for producing a bad telephone for you."

Then he started to tell about how a top-secret project had been launched at Nokia, in which a completely new operating system was being designed. It would result in new kinds of telephones. They would be easy to use and they would change everything.

I met the director again a few years later.

Then it turns out that he had been talking about the Meego. However, the project moved forward slowly, and finally the new CEO Stephen Elop shelved it completely.

This same Nokia executive took one of the many original iPhones Nokia bought home right after it was released.

As an experiment, he gave the telephone to his daughter, and she learned to use it immediately.

In the evening as the parents were going to bed, the drowsy four-year-old appeared at their bedroom door with a question: "Can I take that magic telephone and put it under my pillow tonight?"

That was the moment when the Nokia executive understood that his company was in trouble.

Heart-breaking.

Thread beginning with comment 574320
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Dano
Member since:
2006-01-22


Yeah, sure. Developers loved it, reviewers loved it, users loved it, but nooo, it wasn't good enough.


YOU ARE MISSING THE POINT. It may be good but you can't build a business off of it for external reasons.


There's nothing original to them anymore and they can't even make any hardware that Microsoft doesn't tell them to.


You don't know that. Mostly all of the talent at Nokia is still in place working on the next cycle of phones. Nokia has a 6" model coming out and I want it! I just bought my 925 a month ago!



And speaking out loud is so tens of thousands of year ago -- and yet it still manages to be plenty useful.


If anyone I saw flipped that keyboard out I would be like...damn this guy is a dinosaur. And I myself am old. LOL

Edited 2013-10-10 04:06 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 0

WereCatf Member since:
2006-02-15

YOU ARE MISSING THE POINT. It may be good but you can't build a business off of it for external reasons.


Hm. I'm seeing Jolla doing exactly that.

You don't know that.


Microsoft does dictate the hardware specs.

If anyone I saw flipped that keyboard out I would be like...damn this guy is a dinosaur. And I myself am old. LOL


That just shows ignorance on your part, nothing more. Actual hardware keyboards are faster to type on and for many people much more comfortable than on-screen keyboards, plus they don't require you to stare at the screen to type. Your insistence on the concept of H/W keyboards being inferior because the concept is old is nothing more than elitism.

Reply Parent Score: 3

Dano Member since:
2006-01-22


Hm. I'm seeing Jolla doing exactly that.


What is Jolla? Can I buy it from AT&T? LOL


Microsoft does dictate the hardware specs.


They dictate base hardware specs required for the OS, but the also accommodate the OEMs, and I am sure they are accommodating Nokia designers.


That just shows ignorance on your part, nothing more. Actual hardware keyboards are faster to type on and for many people much more comfortable than on-screen keyboards, plus they don't require you to stare at the screen to type. Your insistence on the concept of H/W keyboards being inferior because the concept is old is nothing more than elitism.


Ignorance? Predictive and Swype-type keyboards SMOKE hardware keyboards. They just raise hardware costs for no advantage. If they were that good then users would be demanding them on more devices. Steve Ballmer used to say that the iPhone would not sell to business users because it did not have a mechanical keyboard...boy was he wrong on that one! Elitism...that's a good one. I don't call you names.

Edited 2013-10-10 04:16 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 0

The123king Member since:
2009-05-28

double posting sucks... And so does the lack of stackable quotes...

Edited 2013-10-10 15:02 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 1

The123king Member since:
2009-05-28

"
Yeah, sure. Developers loved it, reviewers loved it, users loved it, but nooo, it wasn't good enough.


YOU ARE MISSING THE POINT. It may be good but you can't build a business off of it for external reasons.
"What "external reasons"?

"
There's nothing original to them anymore and they can't even make any hardware that Microsoft doesn't tell them to.


You don't know that. Mostly all of the talent at Nokia is still in place working on the next cycle of phones. Nokia has a 6" model coming out and I want it! I just bought my 925 a month ago!
" I swear there was an article on this very site a while ago that said most of the "talent" jumped ship for Jolla...


"
And speaking out loud is so tens of thousands of year ago -- and yet it still manages to be plenty useful.


If anyone I saw flipped that keyboard out I would be like...damn this guy is a dinosaur. And I myself am old. LOL
"
Whilst i myself have never agreed with hardware keyboards on phones, there's a hell of a lot of people who still prefer the haptic feedback you get from a hardware keyboard over a software one. Just saying "Ooooh hardware keyboards are sooooo 1998" just makes you look ignorant.

Edited 2013-10-10 15:01 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 1