Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 30th Nov 2005 16:31 UTC, submitted by Jeremy Jones
.NET (dotGNU too) "How can Microsoft kill Python? When I say 'kill', I mean 'seriously damage the relevance of Python'. I don't mean that Microsoft, as some have suggested, will work on IronPython for a while, get people using it, then hijack the language by seriously changing the syntax of it and thereby breaking compatibility with CPython. So, how does this damage the relevance of Python? If Microsoft, who is investing considerable time and money to create a .Net implementation of Python, only refers to IronPython as a 'dynamic language' and only pushes it as a 'scripting language', many people will begin to assume that that's all that it is good for."
Thread beginning with comment 67201
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Why use IronPython
by on Wed 30th Nov 2005 17:31 UTC

Member since:

Seriously, who is going to use IronPython? What does it get you? The people interested in using Python are rarely going to be those interested in .Net so why combine them?

RE: Why use IronPython
by ma_d on Wed 30th Nov 2005 18:26 in reply to "Why use IronPython"
ma_d Member since:
2005-06-29

It gets you the most powerful and intuitive language and the ability to easily integrate it with a faster language that's not c/c++.

That's all I can think of. I'm not sure how much easier glueing in .net is as compared to using python's c stuff; but that's the only thing I can think of...

Well, there is one added benefit: If your code runs on both, you don't have to ask Windows users to download python. That seems small, but if you don't have to change your code it's a nice benefit!

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 0

RE: Why use IronPython
by Celerate on Wed 30th Nov 2005 22:57 in reply to "Why use IronPython"
Celerate Member since:
2005-06-29

I think some people envision programming languages as going from being compiled into standalone applications, to being compiled into bitecode files that need to be interpreted. Tends seem to indicate that many of those same people also want one interpreter for almost every language there is.

Mind you that was entirely speculation, a momentary thought of mine which I wouldn't have even mentioned if it weren't for your question.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE: Why use IronPython
by on Thu 1st Dec 2005 13:33 in reply to "Why use IronPython"
Member since:

The same reason some techs at MS decided to install windows in a port-a-potty?

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 0