Module Decisions for GNOME 2.16; gtk# To Find Its Way Into GNOME

After all the debate, gtk# will most likely find its way into GNOME. “The release team has completed its second meeting to try to finish the new module decisions. And, after all the long threads on d-d-l and the many discussions amongst ourselves trying to determine community consensus, we finally have the decisions. In summary: orca, alacarte, and gnome-power-manager are in; gtk# and tomboy are in, assuming the issues mentioned are resolved; sticky notes becomes deprecated, assuming tomboy issues are resolved and gets in.” Update: Elijah Newren emailed me concerning an important aspect of the current decision, and asked me to highlight it. So, read more!Elijah asked me to highlight the following part of the decision concerning gtk#:

“New modules may be accepted into the desktop or admin releases with a dependency on gtk#/mono, but any modules accepted into either of those release sets without a dependency on gtk#/mono may not gain one without going through the proposal process again in a subsequent release.”

Eliah explained:

“The ‘but’ clause appears to have missed several peoples’ attention, but I believe it was critical in making this decision palatable to those who strongly opposed any dependency on gtk# (it effectively is an assurance that those who want to remove gtk# will be able to do so without crippling their Gnome installation). I have received at least one email (from the person who I thought was most strongly opposing such a dependency) to that effect. Anyway, I fear that without this rule accompanying the article, people will draw the wrong conclusions about this decision — causing more effort wasted on unnecessary flamage rather than be put to good use on pushing the free/open source desktop forward. That may be an unfounded fear, but it’s one I have nevertheless. ;-)”

Through experience, I think that that fear is anything but unfounded.

115 Comments

  1. aent 2006-08-02 7:07 am EST
    • Ookaze 2006-08-02 8:27 am EST
      • JonPryor 2006-08-02 11:22 am EST
        • chris_dk 2006-08-02 11:31 am EST
        • JonPryor 2006-08-02 1:26 pm EST
          • Bonus 2006-08-02 1:33 pm EST
          • MightyPenguin 2006-08-02 2:17 pm EST
          • samad 2006-08-02 4:45 pm EST
          • HiThere 2006-08-02 5:51 pm EST
          • starnix 2006-08-02 5:55 pm EST
        • rkalla 2006-08-02 1:37 pm EST
      • SEJeff 2006-08-02 12:50 pm EST
        • segedunum 2006-08-02 3:45 pm EST
      • aent 2006-08-02 5:48 pm EST
        • kaiwai 2006-08-02 6:57 pm EST
          • Bonus 2006-08-03 11:56 am EST
  2. miketech 2006-08-02 7:39 am EST
  3. eloy 2006-08-02 7:50 am EST
  4. JMcCarthy 2006-08-02 8:14 am EST
  5. Andre4s 2006-08-02 8:22 am EST
    • thebluesgnr 2006-08-02 3:36 pm EST
      • andrewg 2006-08-02 4:08 pm EST
        • thebluesgnr 2006-08-03 12:04 pm EST
    • duff 2006-08-02 5:37 pm EST
  6. rx182 2006-08-02 8:25 am EST
    • binarycrusader 2006-08-02 8:44 am EST
    • GhePeU 2006-08-02 9:01 am EST
      • szuwar 2006-08-02 9:34 am EST
      • rayiner 2006-08-02 4:06 pm EST
    • tristan 2006-08-02 9:33 am EST
    • mbooth9517 2006-08-02 12:12 pm EST
    • ameasures 2006-08-02 4:09 pm EST
    • theGrump 2006-08-02 4:52 pm EST
    • Bonus 2006-08-03 1:10 pm EST
  7. nzjrs 2006-08-02 8:46 am EST
    • butters 2006-08-03 12:23 am EST
  8. rtehd 2006-08-02 8:59 am EST
    • el3ktro 2006-08-02 9:39 am EST
      • searly 2006-08-02 10:43 am EST
      • binarycrusader 2006-08-02 11:41 am EST
        • rtehd 2006-08-02 3:10 pm EST
  9. Brmbolec 2006-08-02 9:23 am EST
    • snowbender 2006-08-02 9:44 am EST
      • aent 2006-08-02 5:58 pm EST
  10. charlieg 2006-08-02 9:57 am EST
    • chris_dk 2006-08-02 10:12 am EST
    • tristan 2006-08-02 10:15 am EST
      • mkone 2006-08-02 10:32 am EST
      • abraxas 2006-08-02 10:15 pm EST
    • g2devi 2006-08-02 12:20 pm EST
      • JCooper 2006-08-02 1:12 pm EST
    • Mystilleef 2006-08-02 4:29 pm EST
  11. SlackerJack 2006-08-02 10:14 am EST
    • Wrawrat 2006-08-02 12:49 pm EST
  12. Bonus 2006-08-02 10:23 am EST
    • chris_dk 2006-08-02 10:30 am EST
      • Bonus 2006-08-02 12:33 pm EST
        • Bonus 2006-08-02 1:27 pm EST
          • JCooper 2006-08-02 1:34 pm EST
          • Bonus 2006-08-03 11:25 am EST
  13. kaiwai 2006-08-02 10:32 am EST
    • Lambda 2006-08-02 5:10 pm EST
      • kaiwai 2006-08-02 6:53 pm EST
        • mksoft 2006-08-02 7:12 pm EST
        • Lambda 2006-08-02 8:32 pm EST
          • kaiwai 2006-08-03 4:53 am EST
          • drdoug 2006-08-03 1:58 pm EST
    • drdoug 2006-08-03 1:32 pm EST
  14. HiThere 2006-08-02 10:53 am EST
  15. chris_dk 2006-08-02 12:19 pm EST
    • danieldk 2006-08-02 1:00 pm EST
  16. Abaddon 2006-08-02 12:37 pm EST
    • Sphinx 2006-08-02 2:39 pm EST
  17. Mitarai 2006-08-02 1:22 pm EST
  18. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 1:36 pm EST
    • jmansion 2006-08-02 4:11 pm EST
  19. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 1:43 pm EST
  20. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 1:50 pm EST
  21. rajas 2006-08-02 1:51 pm EST
    • kelvin 2006-08-02 3:20 pm EST
      • elsewhere 2006-08-02 4:11 pm EST
    • Lambda 2006-08-02 5:32 pm EST
  22. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 2:00 pm EST
  23. schala 2006-08-02 2:12 pm EST
  24. iiifrank 2006-08-02 2:51 pm EST
    • GhePeU 2006-08-02 5:06 pm EST
      • iiifrank 2006-08-02 5:27 pm EST
        • GhePeU 2006-08-02 5:31 pm EST
          • iiifrank 2006-08-02 5:51 pm EST
  25. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 5:21 pm EST
  26. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 5:25 pm EST
    • JonPryor 2006-08-02 5:39 pm EST
  27. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 5:39 pm EST
  28. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 5:47 pm EST
  29. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 5:50 pm EST
  30. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 5:55 pm EST
    • Lambda 2006-08-02 8:37 pm EST
    • Lambda 2006-08-02 8:42 pm EST
      • sbenitezb 2006-08-02 10:18 pm EST
        • Lambda 2006-08-03 3:40 am EST
  31. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 5:57 pm EST
    • Lambda 2006-08-02 8:41 pm EST
      • sbenitezb 2006-08-02 10:20 pm EST
        • Lambda 2006-08-03 3:41 am EST
  32. sbenitezb 2006-08-02 6:01 pm EST
  33. zerohalo 2006-08-02 8:06 pm EST
  34. Yagami 2006-08-03 10:28 am EST
    • thebluesgnr 2006-08-03 10:44 am EST
      • rajas 2006-08-03 11:10 am EST
      • Bonus 2006-08-03 1:00 pm EST
  35. anda_skoa 2006-08-03 1:02 pm EST
  36. anda_skoa 2006-08-03 1:04 pm EST
    • Bonus 2006-08-03 1:23 pm EST
      • Bonus 2006-08-04 11:08 am EST
  37. kenjiru 2006-08-03 4:56 pm EST