“From a global allocation perspective, actually, it’s quite terrible to have everybody have a bunch of the world’s limited supply of DRAM sitting in their own computer and being used 5% of the time,” Altman said. “You want maximum utilization in the cloud if you’re trying to deal with this very supply-constrained environment. And somehow many people’s intuition is the opposite of that.”
↫ Andrew E. Freedman at Tom’s Hardware
I’m installing a 32bit operating system without support for physical address extension on my laptop with 64GB of RAM, just because I can.

Scammy Sammy, in a fair world, you would end up rotting in jail.
Meanwhile, I’ve got 2 sticks of 32GB SODIMM DDR4 ECC. 25000 EUR a piece. Cash only.
My nvmes are for the grab at 10000 EUR a piece.
What? you got ripped off: https://www.bnn.in.th/en/p/kingston-ram-pc-ddr5-64gb5200mhzcl40-32gbx2-fury-beast-xmp-black-740617326550_d2m88x?ref=ai-search-product-list
35k THB ~ 1k EUR.
you missed the joke. he’s willing to sell them at this price.
Now I look really dumb. Sorry everyone.
And thanks for resolving it for me instead of just laughing, I appreciate.
yup. When I bought the memory, I didn´t know I was doing a financial investment.
There is a reason he has burned so many bridges
First they tried to buy up all future RAM supply with some shady accounting, but after $100 billion “spent” (that did not exist), it hit a wall
They then tried the scare tactics to enact government regulation. It backfired (for one reason or another the current US Admin chose to build more instead of giving them regulatory capture).
Now they are trying to shame the public for having RAM at home. Yet, thanks, but no thanks, I will continue to rock with my 64GB system with no shame, why wouldn’t I?
They are in “begging” stage of grief. Especially after realizing their chief competitor Anthropic turned out to be actually profitable. I will shed no tears.
“Pop! Pop! Pop! Pop!”
— Said to the datacenter bubble in the style of “Chug! Chug! Chug! Chug!”
I’d switch back to computing on my retrocomputing hobby machines before being pushed to their SaaS (Stupidity as a Service).
Hell, people forget how usable a passively cooled 800MHz single-core VIA (low IPC vs. Intel and AMD) thin client running Windows 98 can be with the last supported versions of things like LAVFilters.
Outside of stuff like video editing and 3D modelling, it really is just gaming and web tech that need modern CPUs. (Hell, I have a Windows 7 machine from 2011 that’s stuck at 8GiB of RAM that I use as a “game console but not a console” that already ran 99% of my games beautifully at 1080p 2xAA before I swapped up from a hand-me-down Radeon HD 5870 to a $35 (CAD) GTX670 and from a Core i3-2120 to a $55 (CAD) Core i7-2600S to improve the perf-per-watt.)
I had an Epia @ 800 MHz but it couldn’t even read 720p video with stuttering.
The C7 @ 2 GHz with a FX5200 is a breeze.
The billionaire class have no sympathy for the hardships they create for others. Their greed is unbounded and keeps getting worse. There is no understanding, no compassion, they are so disconnected from the rest of humanity our troubles don’t even register on their scales. And yet the masses have been trained to reliably vote against their own interests in every election.
Musk’s companies alone spent just about half a billion dollars to influence elections in this election cycle. Super PACs and campaigns are some of the best performing investments that billionaires have. It buys them corporate subsidies in the trillions that the rest of us have to pay for. The country should not have to accrue debt when the economy is booming. Seriously their tax cuts net them trillions, meanwhile over $10k of the taxes US families pay each year goes to just paying interest on debt. Yet rather than pay off the debt, we’ve been giving handouts to the corporations who actively use that money to screw consumers even more. It’s insanity.
As the dystopian future painted by 1984 becomes more realistic and less shocking, we may need a new novel to model the dystopian future. Maybe “the time machine”?
https://timemachine.fandom.com/wiki/Morlocks
This makes me want to upgrade my laptop to 32GB. The spec sheet says only 16GB will work, but you knows, screw this guy. I’m going to do it out of spite.
@Clammy Sammy:
I love playing 2D-games on my Ryzen 9800X3D + 64GB DDR5 + RX9070XT machine 🙂
In the mean while, I finished setting up the 3rd node of my homelab proxmox cluster out of scavenged parts.
When not otherwise busy, it will double down as media center connected to my TV in my living room.
Hear that, Sam? A whopping 32GB of RAM, for watching movies!
And I have almost enough spare parts to build another (beefier) computer, which I plan to give to my daughter when she starts attending movie editing classes next semester.
I am glad I over provisioned when pricing was still sane. I might not be running latest generation tech, but it is still plenty fast for the tasks I need it to perform.
I really hope someone starts spending some big token money on optimisations. Apps like the @Craft apps have proven we can get 90% of an apps capability without online subs and integration. I expect i could still use Word 2003 and get everything my family needs done. If only it would run on my system.
If they spend some of their Trillions on that, I wouldnt need to upgrade and they can keep their RAM and id not buy any bits for a decade. It would probably carbon offset an hour or two of data centre time.
@Adurbe, I am a big fan of LLM assisted code, but:
Have you actually tried those applications? They are pretty useless (but shiny)!
Funnily enough – for the only use case I always say I have to fire up my old Power Mac G5 with old Photoshop because GIMP crawls, photocraft worked perfectly! =))))))))
Yeah. Not the the “big ones” but PDFcraft does enough that I dont need to Adobe trial hop anymore (id sign up for multiple trials across emails as I tended to only need it once a week at the very most and sometimes less than once a month, so never justified the cost to pay adobe)
Also on that note, the sheer progress thats been made over the period since launch has been staggering. When I first used it it was pre-alpha. Now its early-beta levels. At the current rate, I can see it being stable enough for most non-critical scenarios
While your needs might differ. I would suggest you give the suite another go. You might be surprised
To be honest I benefit from all of this memory scarcity. In the last 3 years new versions of software applications do not demand more memory.
Ben,
I don’t think these shortages translate into an instantaneous shift. Bloat should stop getting worse, but it may take years for publishers to change course and create new software with a focus on optimization. Software optimization isn’t an on/off switch.
I agree with you software optimization is welcome. There is some evidence for change, such as MS trying to optimize windows for 8GB systems. but as the hardware situation keeps getting worse, the downsides are very significant to many. Even just repairing old computers is a financial burden these days.
“why isn’t anyone using our AI?”
“people cannot buy new computers”
“[Blizzard intensifies] do you guys not have phones?”
“Those require ram as well”
It’s quite terrible to have a bunch of the world’s limited supply of money sitting in one billionaire’s bank account,
Have you looked at M1/M2/M3 recently? Who told you money was limited?
Andreas Reichel,
I think Catweazle’s point is that consumers have less and less buying power because they have to compete with billionaire wealth.
Do you have a good source for a historical consumer price tracker?
I found this one:
https://camelcamelcamel.com/product/B0F2C5NRX4
I believe explains the graph’s discontinuities are caused by large price variations in the used product market (I see this on amazon’s own website today). But looking at the trends it looks like the amazon prices of an M1 max have gone up by a factor of 2X – 3X in a year. Things aren’t much better on the PC side. It’s crazy how much prices have gone up and it’s depressing to think these changes could be permanent. Even the used market is feeling the pressure.
… Wow, I need to proof read more especially after making edits.
@Alfman,
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CPIAUCSL
(St. Louis is an excellent data source, I envy you for that.)
Lol, that was not the M1 I referred too 😀
Most of us here are more familiar with tech jargon than economic jargon.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/moneysupply.asp
Is this whole Open AI sham a speculation scheme on RAM prices? JPMorgan used to do that but for steel and copper (hoarding supply to sell at premium)
Meanwhile, he is not wrong. Although people seem to discover that we sold for decades overpowerful computers being used less than 5% of their capabilities (1 computer, 10h a day, 15% average CPU usage, 5 days a week, 50week a year = 375h vs 8760h per year).
PC Market has been strong and people and enterprises tended to buy one computer by user (even more), so we used precious resources for nearly nothing, thanks to commercial messages.
Centralising all in datacenters could allow to boost usage. Even more: maximising usage in datacenters could be more efficient, because we would need less of that security crap (less time needed for antiviruses, EDRs, (de)cyphering, …)
I am not a fan, I am really into computing (and I own a lot of computers), but I understand the point.
doubleUb,
It’s not the math that people are upset about though, it’s the fact that AI companies are creating this shortage and using it to justify our dependency on tethered services…that’s F’ed up. For better or worse those with an irrational amount of wealth are transforming markets for the worse for the rest of us. My question is whether things will ever bounce back or if this is truly permanent? People are getting really sick and tired of corporate rent-seeking practices in general, but with corporations holding nearly all the cards, this could be where all the markets eventually converge at.
This was how anti-trust and monopoly control was invented — and I wonder why I never have heard from those people again after 2007 or so.
How exactly are the Magnificent 7 not trust/monopolies?
Andreas Reichel,
Corporations bought both parties in washington, strategically flipping with the political tide. Obviously corruption is way more overt in the republican party, but most Democrats are beholden to corporate interests as well. A few representatives like Bernie Sanders do hold corporations accountable, but neither party encapsulate those values. The establishment famously went with Hilary to represent the party instead. Being an independent is good in my book, but independents are drowned out by the US two party duopoly.
The “blue wave” in recent elections is good insofar as being able to put a check on the most corrupt and self serving president to take the office. But it remains to be seen what, if any,thing will be done to address corporate greed and abuses. Democracy ostensibly exists to serve actual people and not corporations, but corporations keep having success playing their “heads I win, tails you loose” game. I’m extremely skeptical of either duopoly party fixing it.
Why worry about under-utilized computers? The average car sits around for something like 96% of the time (iirc). That is a much bigger squandering of resources, and also my computer does not demand large areas of street space or parking bays at every website I visit. Much better to scrap most of them (except for a small car-share fleet) and use public transport for most trips.