‘A Web OS? Are you Dense?’

With all the recent hype surrounding Google’s Chrome, it’s refreshing to see someone taking a few steps back and looking at the bigger picture. Superlatives were abound about Chrome (I personally really like it), but some people really took it overboard – take TechCrunch for instance: “Chrome is nothing less than a full on desktop operating system that will compete head on with Windows.” Seeing my nationality, I know a tulip mania when I see one. So does Ted Dziuba.

All it takes for him to explain that no, a web browser is not an operating system, is three images. The three high-quality images, made in a simple image editor, pretty much sum up why I believe this mythical web operating system, over which every web journalist wets its pants, will remain a pipe dream. Dzubia sums up:

Users have pretty basic needs when it comes to computers. They want word processing, spreadsheets, communications, and games. These needs have not changed much since the advent of the personal computer. So, when your Aunt asks why her 1.2GHz computer isn’t fast enough to run an online word processor that has the same fucking features as the 1987 version of Corel WordPerfect, you don’t have an answer for her. There is no justification.

Google Chrome is a nice web browser for a beta release, but it’s not really revolutionary or all that earth-shattering as some make it out to be, and it most certainly isn’t an operating system. Ground, feet, keep. You put them together.

51 Comments

  1. fretinator 2008-09-08 9:12 pm EST
  2. hyriand 2008-09-08 9:18 pm EST
  3. krreagan 2008-09-08 10:11 pm EST
    • Liquidator 2008-09-09 6:33 am EST
    • wannabe geek 2008-09-09 9:55 am EST
  4. hobgoblin 2008-09-08 10:24 pm EST
  5. umccullough 2008-09-08 11:24 pm EST
    • WereCatf 2008-09-08 11:31 pm EST
  6. buff 2008-09-08 11:30 pm EST
    • modmans2ndcoming 2008-09-09 3:40 am EST
  7. drcoldfoot 2008-09-08 11:41 pm EST
    • helf 2008-09-09 12:29 am EST
    • buff 2008-09-10 12:38 am EST
      • drcoldfoot 2008-09-10 3:41 pm EST
  8. Morph 2008-09-09 1:26 am EST
    • evangs 2008-09-09 7:14 am EST
  9. TechGeek 2008-09-09 3:06 am EST
    • computrius 2008-09-09 4:48 am EST
      • yiyus 2008-09-09 10:33 am EST
      • TechGeek 2008-09-09 2:05 pm EST
    • Bully 2008-09-09 1:57 pm EST
      • TechGeek 2008-09-09 2:10 pm EST
        • Bully 2008-09-09 2:19 pm EST
  10. Mediv 2008-09-09 5:25 am EST
    • evangs 2008-09-09 7:10 am EST
  11. goddang 2008-09-09 6:14 am EST
  12. Traumflug 2008-09-09 8:20 am EST
  13. chaosvoyager 2008-09-09 8:53 am EST
    • evangs 2008-09-09 12:23 pm EST
  14. cg0def 2008-09-09 9:29 am EST
  15. RIchard James13 2008-09-09 11:47 am EST
    • GavHSS 2008-09-09 12:05 pm EST
      • RIchard James13 2008-09-09 12:28 pm EST
        • Kroc 2008-09-10 8:36 am EST
    • raver31 2008-09-09 6:52 pm EST
      • RIchard James13 2008-09-10 11:11 am EST
        • wrocic 2008-09-10 5:43 pm EST
        • WereCatf 2008-09-10 6:07 pm EST
  16. Moonbuzz 2008-09-09 11:50 am EST
  17. BigDaddy 2008-09-09 12:55 pm EST
  18. TemporalBeing 2008-09-09 4:29 pm EST
  19. sorpigal 2008-09-09 4:35 pm EST
    • kristalsoldier 2008-09-09 4:50 pm EST
      • egarland 2008-09-09 5:00 pm EST
        • kristalsoldier 2008-09-09 5:07 pm EST
          • egarland 2008-09-09 6:51 pm EST
          • kristalsoldier 2008-09-09 7:38 pm EST
          • sorpigal 2008-09-09 8:04 pm EST
          • kristalsoldier 2008-09-09 8:26 pm EST
      • sorpigal 2008-09-09 7:58 pm EST
  20. Peter Besenbruch 2008-09-09 8:16 pm EST