No proof of ‘Copy-the-iPhone’-order from Samsung

Previously redacted documents presented in the Apple-Samsung case do not support Apple’s claims that Samsung issued a ‘copy-the-iPhone’-order to its designers. It’s pretty damning. Apple has very selectively and actively deleted sections of internal Samsung documents and talks to make it seem as if Samsung’s designers were ordered to copy the iPhone. With the unredacted, full documents without Apple’s deletions in hand, a completely different picture emerges: Samsung’s designers are told to be as different and creative as possible. There’s no ‘copy the iPhone’-order anywhere, as Apple claimed. Instead, it says this: “designers rightly must make their own designs with conviction and confidence; do not strive to do designs to please me (the president); instead make designs with faces that are creative and diverse.” I guess my initial scepticism about the documents was not uncalled for. What do you know – lawyers twist and turn the truth. Shocker, huh?

74 Comments

  1. MollyC 2012-10-08 10:41 pm EST
    • jared_wilkes 2012-10-08 11:07 pm EST
      • Thom Holwerda 2012-10-08 11:24 pm EST
        • jared_wilkes 2012-10-08 11:52 pm EST
          • kwan_e 2012-10-09 12:04 am EST
          • przemo_li 2012-10-09 9:11 am EST
          • Bill Shooter of Bul 2012-10-09 9:20 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 9:38 pm EST
        • Tony Swash 2012-10-09 2:26 pm EST
      • przemo_li 2012-10-09 9:07 am EST
        • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 1:21 pm EST
  2. jared_wilkes 2012-10-08 11:00 pm EST
  3. Hiev 2012-10-08 11:16 pm EST
  4. oper 2012-10-08 11:32 pm EST
  5. arb1 2012-10-09 12:00 am EST
  6. kristoph 2012-10-09 1:11 am EST
    • Thom Holwerda 2012-10-09 8:22 am EST
  7. Lorin 2012-10-09 3:01 am EST
    • 1c3d0g 2012-10-09 3:48 am EST
      • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 1:24 pm EST
  8. jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 3:19 am EST
    • Thom Holwerda 2012-10-09 8:17 am EST
      • siraf72 2012-10-09 8:40 am EST
        • Morgan 2012-10-09 10:27 am EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 2:55 pm EST
          • anevilyak 2012-10-09 3:20 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 5:41 pm EST
          • anevilyak 2012-10-09 6:03 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 7:24 pm EST
          • Morgan 2012-10-09 8:17 pm EST
          • siraf72 2012-10-10 12:02 pm EST
      • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 1:27 pm EST
      • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 1:32 pm EST
        • Thom Holwerda 2012-10-09 1:52 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 2:01 pm EST
          • Thom Holwerda 2012-10-09 2:15 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 2:38 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 2:49 pm EST
  9. bansal98 2012-10-09 3:49 am EST
    • unclefester 2012-10-09 5:42 am EST
    • Sauron 2012-10-09 8:35 am EST
    • aldo 2012-10-09 4:16 pm EST
      • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 4:23 pm EST
        • aldo 2012-10-09 4:38 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-09 4:51 pm EST
          • aldo 2012-10-10 8:26 am EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 3:38 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 3:42 pm EST
  10. siraf72 2012-10-09 8:32 am EST
  11. bowkota 2012-10-09 9:59 am EST
  12. MOS6510 2012-10-09 1:21 pm EST
    • anevilyak 2012-10-09 3:22 pm EST
  13. Janvl 2012-10-09 7:47 pm EST
  14. TechGeek 2012-10-09 11:32 pm EST
    • Thom Holwerda 2012-10-10 6:01 am EST
    • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 3:36 pm EST
      • Thom Holwerda 2012-10-10 4:00 pm EST
        • MOS6510 2012-10-10 4:25 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 4:28 pm EST
          • MOS6510 2012-10-10 4:45 pm EST
        • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 4:27 pm EST
          • Thom Holwerda 2012-10-10 4:39 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 4:54 pm EST
          • Thom Holwerda 2012-10-10 5:03 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 5:13 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 5:27 pm EST
          • Thom Holwerda 2012-10-10 5:33 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 5:37 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 6:36 pm EST
          • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 7:36 pm EST
          • TM99 2012-10-11 8:10 am EST
      • Bennie 2012-10-10 4:55 pm EST
        • jared_wilkes 2012-10-10 5:02 pm EST
      • TechGeek 2012-10-11 2:54 pm EST