Linked by Eugenia Loli-Queru on Thu 19th Jul 2007 06:51 UTC
Multimedia, AV Geeks.com sent us over one of the best video cards on the market today: the GeForce 86000GTS with 256 MB VRAM and a crazy fast 675 MHz engine clock. The card is on the high side of the middle-end graphics cards compared to others available and it's currently selling below $200. In this article we will test the multimedia performance of the card as used in video playback and rendering support rather than its already well-benchmarked multiple times so far and well-known gaming abilities.
Thread beginning with comment 256405
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
ATI What?
by SilentStorm on Thu 19th Jul 2007 07:51 UTC
SilentStorm
Member since:
2006-09-22

IIRC I can decode h264 content since my 9600XT and use shader stuff to process video. (ATI had a demo about that too)

OTOH, What is Ati X100? X1K? X1300/1600/1650 or what card...

A quick glance to article shows some bias traces in the writing and I personally want some more details on ATI card and want a comparison with X2400 or above card to play in even fields.

As a conclusion: ATI Cards can decode and process this thing since 9500 and up.

RE: ATI What?
by Eugenia on Thu 19th Jul 2007 08:06 in reply to "ATI What?"
Eugenia Member since:
2005-06-28

I believe that the card is a rebranded version (possibly manufactured specifically for DELL, as that's the model name that my receipt says) of the ATi X300 with 128 MB RAM, PCI-e, one DVI and one VGA ports. Dell calls it X100, but feel free to call it X300. The PC was purchased in March 2005, if that helps you further to locate which card it is exactly.

> shows some bias traces

There is no bias. It is SIMPLY my EXPERIENCE from my old ATi card to this new GeForce card. I have used no other card in the last 2 years in that PC.

>and want a comparison with X2400

You are in no position to demand anything. This site is not Tom's Hardware where they have 10,000 graphics cards laying around them and they can pick and choose for their articles. These cards were tested in my personal machine and I simply wrote about my impressions after doing that upgrade last Saturday. I found the multimedia performance to be an important upgrading, so I wrote about it.

I am pretty sure that ATi has other recent technologies that do similar things, but I am in no position to test them. Feel free to send me one of these newer cards, and I will make sure that I will update my article accordingly! Until then, what I have in my lab will have to do.

So, take it easy when you have your expectancy of a graphics card review UP THERE. This is not your casual 3D gaming review, but from the point of view of someone who upgraded to a new card and saw a significant multimedia performance increase in the *2D and video space*. There is nothing more, and nothing less into it.

Edited 2007-07-19 08:22

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE[2]: ATI What?
by SilentStorm on Thu 19th Jul 2007 10:37 in reply to "RE: ATI What?"
SilentStorm Member since:
2006-09-22

While I do not object to the points you raise (in poisition to demand, the rebrand and other all) I just wanted some clairification and tried to point that cards are just "uneven"...

Since the review is short, and the uneven comparison makes the review "smell" biased.

Yes, my language may sound a bit inflammatory (I'm not intended to do it) and I'm really sorry for that but unfortunately I'm not a gamer and I don't read "casual 3D gaming reviews" but slashdot, OSNews and such. I'm just a linux programmer who works with low-level stuff and love watching movies.

I just expected a clearer article, my bad.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 4

RE: ATI What?
by Eugenia on Thu 19th Jul 2007 08:14 in reply to "ATI What?"
Eugenia Member since:
2005-06-28

ok, I found some more info about the specific card sold with the specific DELL workstation. The card was rebranded but under the hood was just the "ATi X300 SE PCI Express 128 MB".

Edited 2007-07-19 08:18

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE: ATI What?
by ronaldst on Thu 19th Jul 2007 08:22 in reply to "ATI What?"
ronaldst Member since:
2005-06-29

A quick glance to article shows some bias traces in the writing and I personally want some more details on ATI card and want a comparison with X2400 or above card to play in even fields.


Out with guns blazing!

You're serious? She said that it was her old card. It was just a smallish review on how nice the speed bump is with the new more RECENT video card. And there you had to crucify her for something she never intentionaly meant to do.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 4

RE[2]: ATI What?
by Eugenia on Thu 19th Jul 2007 08:23 in reply to "RE: ATI What?"
Eugenia Member since:
2005-06-28

Thanks Ronald, appreciated! ;)

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE[2]: ATI What?
by SilentStorm on Thu 19th Jul 2007 10:38 in reply to "RE: ATI What?"
SilentStorm Member since:
2006-09-22

When you use a rebranded ford to race with a ferrari,
race looks biased to ferrari. It's that simple.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 0

RE: ATI What?
by AdamW on Thu 19th Jul 2007 08:33 in reply to "ATI What?"
AdamW Member since:
2005-07-06

Note the resolution. Is the stuff you're playing back on your 9600XT 1920x1080?

I can play 1280x720 smoothly with an FX5200, but 1920x1080 is 2.25x that resolution...

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2