To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
I'm not saying that they shouldn't try. I was just saying that they will probably have limited success in the "full-size" desktop area. With that said, if I were designing an X-less GUI Linux, Enlightenment looks like it would be a good place to start. Since PDAs and the like need an X-less GUI, I also predicted that Enlightenment might well be more succsful in the handheld/palmtop/PDA market than in the "bid" system market.
i think that we have radically different opinions as to the maturity levels of certain linux markets. I'm not saying you are wrong, because i can understand your side of these things, i just disagree. I think that the linux desktop is just as much a starter market as the pda/cellphone/etc. scene. I do agree with you that it is unlikely that E17 will over take the big 2 of linux DE's, but there is always room for more in the open source world. It seems like you are implying that E17 for desktops is not a good use of developer time, because it is unlikely to compete with KDE/Gnome. People have said this about the linux desktop for years, yet it is slowly starting to make head room. Hell, i don't even use linux, but i find that statements like "... the Linux desktop market simply isn't big enough to support a third major environment" are neither true, nor productive.






Member since:
2007-09-27
this is one of those arguments that really boggles my mind. Honestly, this is the same argument as "we already have windows and OS X, linux should stick to servers". I always feel way too preachy when i say this, but open source is about choice. Just because KDE and Gnome are dominant, doesn't mean they are the right choices for every one. Some people see a lot of value in a low resource desktop that still looks beautiful, even if they use it on a 4 core processor. I really don't understand people's need to have a 2 party system all the time, especially in the open source world.
Edited 2007-11-06 20:36