Linked by weildish on Wed 4th Feb 2009 07:07 UTC
Windows Windows 7 was causing quite a bit of hype months before its release, and now that it's finally out into the void, you'd think people would be contentedly beta-ing the system and be happy to wait until the wrinkles are smoothed, right? Apparently not, at least for a certain Kelly Poe and now over 2,500 Windows 7 enthusiasts.
E-mail Print r 0   · Read More · 23 Comment(s)
Thread beginning with comment 347038
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Release Windows 7 now???
by protagonist on Wed 4th Feb 2009 07:43 UTC
Member since:

I have been using the public beta since it came out and have found it surprisingly easy to bring it to its knees. That is not to say I don't like it, but rather it is definietly not ready for release to the average Windows user.

If I had to choose between the Windows 7 beta and Vista I would take the beta. That being said there is not enough there to woo be back from the dark side. :-)

Reply Score: 3

RE: Release Windows 7 now???
by Thom_Holwerda on Wed 4th Feb 2009 07:47 in reply to "Release Windows 7 now???"
Thom_Holwerda Member since:

and have found it surprisingly easy to bring it to its knees

I use my computers for light tasks only, so could you give some examples? I'm not doubting you - I'm just curious as I never get to do any stress testing to find the breaking points myself ;) .

Reply Parent Score: 1

weildish Member since:

In my experience with 7, the main problems I've had are:

-Graphics drivers. The system sometimes will randomly crash after the screens flicker in and out for a few minutes, not letting me do anything. I don't believe I was doing anything graphics intensive, either. This has happened to me in Vista, too, but not as much. For the record, I have an HIS Radeon HD 2600 XT.

-Printer drivers. The driver base for printers seemed reduced compared to Vista-- in that the drivers for my printers weren't included as they were on Vista. I had to go out and download Vista drivers, and even then the printing for me seemed a bit buggy at times.

-Having dual monitors wouldn't allow the screensaver to work nor my Google Talk to go idle. Definitely not bringing the system to its knees, but still annoying nonetheless. It suddenly fixed itself, though.

-My sidebar (which isn't really a bar at all anymore) gadgets won't appear anymore, and I can't open the sidebar config program. Again, not to the knees, but still.

I've yet to edit video with Adobe Premiere with it or to run any games on it. Once I get Supreme Commander back from my brother-in-law, I may try it with 7. That's a pretty graphic-intensive game. I may also try running 3DMark with it to compare with the points I got with Vista.

Overall, I think the system's shaping up pretty well, especially for a beta. But I don't think it's ready for a release now. As for whether the site is for Windows fanboys to band together and give MS the thumbs up, I don't know-- it sure seems more like he wanted to petition MS to release it prematurely-- but here's my thumbs up:

**gives a thumbs up with a cheesy smile**

I approve, MS. I approve. Just work out the bugs, and I'll be a happy Windows user.

Reply Parent Score: 1

John Blink Member since:

I will give you a simple example.

I installed it on my eeepc 1000hd.

It detected all drivers except ethernet and intel video.

I installed the drivers, played an xvid and windows 7 locked up couldn't move the mouse or press the start key on the keyboard to shut it down.

PS. I didn't try playing an xvid file before installing those drivers. It may have been a driver issue.

But it did lock up on a fresh install.

Reply Parent Score: 3

RE[2]: Release Windows 7 now???
by grat on Wed 4th Feb 2009 15:20 in reply to "RE: Release Windows 7 now???"
grat Member since:

I've got the beta on two systems... a homebuilt AMD / NVidia desktop, and it's been fine. No crashes, and very few quirks.

Then there's the year old Vaio laptop. Not all the vista drivers work (some won't load, some will load and not work, some load and work), and playing a video usually results in a BSOD and a memory dump. It was too unstable for use, so I went back to Vista.

Reply Parent Score: 2