Linked by Thom Holwerda on Fri 8th Jun 2012 23:07 UTC
Hardware, Embedded Systems Two weeks ago, my grandmother passed away - the last grandparent I had left. As those of you with experience in dealing with deceased family members know, the funeral is only the start; the next part is taking care of the deceased's affairs, which includes going through all their belongings to determine what to do with them. I took care of my grandmother's extensive book collection, and while doing so, I hit something that fascinated me to no end: a six-volume Christian Encyclopaedia from 1956. In it, I found something I just had to share with OSNews.
Thread beginning with comment 521676
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
frajo
Member since:
2007-06-29

"
The statement "god exists" is not falsifiable.
The statement "god doesn't exist" is not falsifiable.


These statements strike me as too strong; rather I would suggest, "I do not know the statement 'god exists' to be falsifiable", and "I do not know the statement 'god doesn't exist' to be falsifiable".
"

But the statement
A: "God exists"
is not of the same quality as the statement
A': "The statement 'God exists' is not falsifiable".

This is so because A' is certainly falsifiable.
You just have to prove that A is falsifiable in order to falsify A'.

The same holds true for the statements
B: "God doesn't exist"
and
B': "The statement 'God doesn't exist' is not falsifiable".
B' is certainly falsifiable as it suffices to show that B is falsifiable.

Therefore, my statements (A' and B') are of scientific nature (as they are falsifiable)
while the statements A and B have to be regarded unfalsifiable, i.e. unscientific, until the day someone shows their falsifiability.

Reply Parent Score: 1

james_parker Member since:
2005-06-29

"[q]
The statement "god exists" is not falsifiable.
The statement "god doesn't exist" is not falsifiable.


These statements strike me as too strong; rather I would suggest, "I do not know the statement 'god exists' to be falsifiable", and "I do not know the statement 'god doesn't exist' to be falsifiable".
"

But the statement
A: "God exists"
is not of the same quality as the statement
A': "The statement 'God exists' is not falsifiable".

This is so because A' is certainly falsifiable.
You just have to prove that A is falsifiable in order to falsify A'.
[/q]

I see no convincing evidence that A' is falsifiable; please demonstrate this.

Reply Parent Score: 2