Linked by Thom Holwerda on Fri 13th Jul 2012 23:39 UTC
Windows Ars Technica is running an interesting article about the Mail application on Windows 8. It's one of the first party Metro applications, and Ars' conclusion is that it's really, really not up to snuff - it can't even compare favourably to the mail application on Windows Phone. The sad thing is, however - this applies to virtually all Metro applications.
Thread beginning with comment 527007
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
One of many "Achilles Heels" in the OS
by jnemesh on Mon 16th Jul 2012 18:11 UTC
jnemesh
Member since:
2008-04-08

Poor quality "Metro" apps are just the beginning of the headaches Windows 8 users will encounter!

You also have a completely redesigned UI that is NOT friendly to keyboard and mouse operation. (just try "swiping" with a mouse! It's ridiculous!)

You also have the depreciation of the desktop environment (no start button), poor multi-monitor support, locked down hardware that makes it next to impossible to dual boot your system to another OS, a "walled garden" ecosystem that locks out "unapproved" software from even RUNNING, and to top it all off you will probably have to buy new hardware.

This is shaping up to be a failure of epic proportions! Good job Ballmer! You just ensured your own early retirement!

Reply Score: 0

WereCatf Member since:
2006-02-15

poor multi-monitor support


Actually people are saying it's better than in Win7.

locked down hardware that makes it next to impossible to dual boot your system to another OS


On ARM-devices, yes. On x86-devices you can just disable SecureBoot or buy a motherboard without it at all.

a "walled garden" ecosystem that locks out "unapproved" software from even RUNNING


This applies only to Metro-applications, not regular ones.

and to top it all off you will probably have to buy new hardware.


Windows 8 will run just fine on anything that runs Windows 7.

Reply Parent Score: 2

AnythingButVista Member since:
2008-08-27

You also have a completely redesigned UI that is NOT friendly to keyboard and mouse operation. (just try "swiping" with a mouse! It's ridiculous!)

Actually the Windows 8 UI is much friendlier to keyboard users than it is to mouse users.

Need the Charms via the keyboard? Press WindowsKey+C and they are immediately there -- you even have some hotkeys to jump to specific charms. Need to close an app via the keyboard? Press ALT+F4 and kiss it goodbye.

Need the Charms via the mouse? You have to hover on the right edge of the screen and wait for the darn things to appear. Need to close an application via the mouse? Move to the top edge of the screen and drag a non-existent border down. Seriously, Metro is like hell for a mouse user. Most of the time you'll be waiting for stuff keyboard and touchscreen users can access immediately.

The sad thing is Microsoft is proving us right. All of us who said Metro was a crappy tabletized environment that could not handle serious tasks and as meant for Twitter posters and weather checkers... Well, not even Microsoft could make their serious programs (Office, Registry Editor, Windows Explorer, etc.) as fully-featured Metro applications, which is why we are constantly jumping back and forth from Metro to Desktop and back to Metro.

Edited 2012-07-16 19:51 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 2