Linked by boldingd on Tue 29th Jan 2013 23:12 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 550852
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[4]: Comment by Wafflez
by Soulbender on Thu 31st Jan 2013 02:07
in reply to "RE[3]: Comment by Wafflez"
The games the are open source, while some of them are very good are usually knock-offs of popular 90s games (Nexuiz/Xonotic - Q3/UT) being a good examples
Sad but true. I'm constantly disappointing by the number of FPS clones the OSS community manage to create. Sometime it seems that like every new OSS game is yet another stale FPS clone.
It's doubly sad because the there's no inherent reason why the open source model (and perhaps combined with creative commons) shouldn't work for creating new and innovative games.
RE[5]: Comment by Wafflez
by WereCatf on Thu 31st Jan 2013 03:39
in reply to "RE[4]: Comment by Wafflez"
It's doubly sad because the there's no inherent reason why the open source model (and perhaps combined with creative commons) shouldn't work for creating new and innovative games.
I'd say there kind of is in practice: creating a compelling story, designing the interaction mechanics between the player and the game-world in a meaningful way, real interface design, doing all the graphical and audio assets -- ie. all very much artistic assets -- pay quite well in the real world. In addition, creating such assets tend to be really, really time-consuming, much more so than cranking out code, and therefore such just may not be deemed worth the peoples' efforts and time.
It's not the amount of coders available that is the problem, it's the lack of everyone else. Even a project leader with a well-defined, uncompromising vision could give these F/OSS - games some much-needed direction, but as it stands, these projects are mostly collections of random, shallow ideas thrown together.





Member since:
2009-08-18
The problem is with games is that while there are large amounts of people involved, the collaborative model doesn't really work with something that is at it very core creative and more like art than something technical.
The games the are open source, while some of them are very good are usually knock-offs of popular 90s games (Nexuiz/Xonotic - Q3/UT) being a good examples.
Indie games are quite popular these days because they were given an audience through things like the humble bundle, steam and whatever they call Xbox Live Arcade.
Edited 2013-01-30 08:07 UTC