To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Edgy Eft builds upon Dapper, and Dapper is rock solid. There are a few things under the hood that are indeed new, but generally speaking it is an evolving thing.
What I don't understand about Vista: What is so damn new about it that it justifies such a long development circle? I completely fail to see that. But maybe it's just me ...
What is so damn new about it...?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Features_new_to_Windows_Vista
aent, are you trying to tell me that with a release for Edgy Eft due in October Knot 2 and Knot 3 are only Alpha State releases?
They are considered alpha by the Ubuntu release team. Of course, since the release cycle is much shorter than Vista's, it takes a lot less time to go from alpha to beta to release.
with Vista it is of a less evolving natuture compared to Linux as when MS gets a solid release they usually sit on it for a while where as Linux continues (Ubuntu 6mth release schedule).
There are distributions that try to provide the latest developments in the floss world, and others that try to build a solid, stable release to be supported for a very long time.
"are you trying to tell me that with a release for Edgy Eft due in October Knot 2 and Knot 3 are only Alpha State releases?"
That's how Ubuntu themselves describe it:
"The Edgy Eft Knot 3 is the third alpha release of Ubuntu 6.10"
http://www.ubuntu.com/testing/knot3
And here's their development schedule:
https://wiki.ubuntu.com/EdgyReleaseSchedule
"In a word, both a far from ready at this point in time."
That would mean that MS is lying about their release actually being a Release Candidate.
I'd agree that both are ready at this point in time, however one is labeled ALPHA while the other one is labeled to be a candidate for RELEASE. Ubuntu is scheduled to go into beta with the appropiate freezes in one week, where then there will be a heavy focus on getting it ready for release by the time the RC is released. At that time, critical remaining bugs will be fixed, not a lot of release work that was known about for a long time. Edgy did have a shorter then usual release cycle (4 months)...




Member since:
2006-09-15
aent, are you trying to tell me that with a release for Edgy Eft due in October Knot 2 and Knot 3 are only Alpha State releases?
Wouldn't the Ubuntu team be cutting it way short if that was the case?
At least Vista is getting a second Release Candidate and will not be let out onto the public until early next year at the very earliest.
I am more of the thinking that they are at a relatively similar state of development but with Vista it is of a less evolving natuture compared to Linux as when MS gets a solid release they usually sit on it for a while where as Linux continues (Ubuntu 6mth release schedule).
In a word, both a far from ready at this point in time.