Linked by Amjith Ramanujam on Thu 24th Jul 2008 21:12 UTC, submitted by sharkscott
Linux The GNU/Linux operating system is blessed to have sound partition management tools like GParted which are very easy to use. However, when it comes to the management of 'virtual partitions' known as volumes, things are quite different. There is Linux Volume Management, or LVM for short, however it can only really be used from the command line.
Thread beginning with comment 324425
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Absurd
by tene on Thu 24th Jul 2008 22:41 UTC
tene
Member since:
2008-07-24

This is ridiculous.

I just walked over to one of the machines in this lab and set up his initial configuration with software raid and lvm2, resized it down, and created new partitions at the end of the disks, like he wanted.

It took me like 10 minutes, including checking the options in the man pages. I'll do it again and post a transcript if anyone wants it.

This article is not about LVM at all as the summary suggested. This article is complaining about EVMS being obsolete.

Also, system-config-lvm is open-source. It's not red hat's fault if your distro doesn't choose to provide it.

RE: Absurd
by stabbyjones on Thu 24th Jul 2008 23:29 in reply to "Absurd"
stabbyjones Member since:
2008-04-15

there have been a lot of articles lately bitching about when things go wrong for one person. (Linux Live Journal Syndrome?)

i can understand that there are problems just waiting to happen. i enjoy causing myself pain playing around like this but things are hardly a mess.

will autocad install in a VM? i don't see why it wouldn't. that would have saved the effort when your partition scheme isn't what you need.

and since when does something have to be in a repo to be usable? compiling LVM from source isn't a killer and running zfs for two 80 gb drives seems like overkill.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE[2]: Absurd
by hobgoblin on Fri 25th Jul 2008 13:06 in reply to "RE: Absurd"
hobgoblin Member since:
2005-07-06

im starting to wonder if the writer was grasping for geek cred, had it blow up in his face and blames linux for it rather then consider the silliness of what he was trying to do...

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 4

RE: Absurd
by bousozoku on Fri 25th Jul 2008 05:26 in reply to "Absurd"
bousozoku Member since:
2006-01-23

This is ridiculous.

I just walked over to one of the machines in this lab and set up his initial configuration with software raid and lvm2, resized it down, and created new partitions at the end of the disks, like he wanted.

It took me like 10 minutes, including checking the options in the man pages. I'll do it again and post a transcript if anyone wants it.

This article is not about LVM at all as the summary suggested. This article is complaining about EVMS being obsolete.

Also, system-config-lvm is open-source. It's not red hat's fault if your distro doesn't choose to provide it.


Was that your first time using it?

I'm not saying that it can't be done correctly first time that quickly with some research, but it seems a bit quick for someone like the author, who had Gentoo installed for him and who was generally unknowledgeable about Linux.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE[2]: Absurd
by tene on Fri 25th Jul 2008 13:51 in reply to "RE: Absurd"
tene Member since:
2008-07-24

No, it wasn't my first time using it.

I'm not saying that some man pages might be intimidating, but this article isn't about the modern tools at all. It's about EVMS, which is old and outdated and unsupported.

If it's just a blog post about some guy who was in an awkward situation, that's fine, but trying to draw conclusions about the state of modern volume management tools from it is a poor choice.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1