Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sat 28th Feb 2009 11:47 UTC
Apple A few days ago, Apple surprised everyone by releasing the first beta of Safari 4, the company's latest version of their WebKit browser. While I generally love Safari on the Mac (my browser of choice on that side of the fence), I've never felt as comfortable with it on the Windows side of things. In any case, this latest beta has made a very bold move in the interface department, and I'm sad to say that it's not for the better. Let me explain where it went wrong for Apple.
Thread beginning with comment 351134
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Is it dead yet?
by innovati on Sat 28th Feb 2009 23:39 UTC
innovati
Member since:
2009-02-28

reading this rant put a few thoughts into my head.

1) Before I even read the author, I thought: wow, either OSnews is really lowering the standards of what it takes to publish an article, or some 13 year old accidentally hacked the site. When I saw it was a regular poster I then wondered what sort of lacking editorial process the site must have, and how freakishly lucky I've been to have no been exposed to such trash on this site before (and I've been reading for years).

2) Did you actually use the Safari beta? Do you understand what the word Beta means? Typically it's because the software isn't done, but they want to test it. You criticize the fact that the tabs are there and that they aren't perfect, but instead of actually writing a coherent and informed article, you just trash the work they're doing. Nobody from the Apple camp has claimed they are perfect. Sure the feature is in there and there's a hidden option to turn it off, but why would htey roll out a beta with all of the new testing features disabled? that's why they have Safari3.

Now, I will clarify, I'm somebody who keeps daily updates of webkit, and developer version of Firefox as my two main browsers. I'm used to buggy, incomplete and promosing software. Perhaps this venture into 'non-released software' was too much for you to handle, but I would think it would be more embarrassing to whine about how you can't handle change than to just shut up and use non-beta software.

3) Did you even use Safari4 beta on OS X? I really can't associate with half of what you've written here, and when you gave examples, I'm totally unable to find what you're talking about on my OS X install of it - if you are in fact using the Windows version, had you considered that maybe the problems are windows specific?

4) Lets see your suggestions - come on now, lets mockup, animate, or actually code up a better solution - or is that too far beyond you overly developed skillset of whining and complaining when people try to make current software? Where's your solution to it - or are you too afraid that if you tell us what you think is better, there will be far to many people who are more qualified than you who will use evil and means things like 'Logic' and 'Rational Thought' to pick apart the flaws in your design?

-----

Now, I've been reading your posts for years, and I've seen the transition from just a poster here to a self-appointed UI consultant, but what I have never seen is a single shred of actual UI work you've done. I dont' mind if you say: hey, I'm a UI thinker and this is what I think as a critical user of this software. But when you roll in here and assume Apple has hired total idiots who obviously don't have training or industry experience, and that you, somebody whose only experience is writing on a blog, has FAR more wisdom than a team of industry professionals, it comes across as a little arrogant. Sure, even the best teams make mistakes, but we all know this is a work-in-progress, and please wait until the end to judge.

If you have anything CONSTRUCTIVE to say about how they can solve the issues you as a mere mortal user feel are problems, I'm sure they would love to hear your ideas about solving those issues or finding better ways to present the same information. IF you are not prepared to offer anything constructive or helpful, please, don't insult the intelligence and education of your readers by writing more articles.

I'm sorry to have read this - I lost a lot of faith in you.

Reply Score: 1