Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 8th Oct 2009 19:09 UTC, submitted by MadMAtt
Linux Lennart Poettering, creator of open source sound server PulseAudio, was recently interviewed at this year's Linux Plumbers Conference. In this Q&A he details the latest PulseAudio developments and addresses some of PA's critics. Thanks to PulseAudio, the Linux audio experience is becoming more context-aware. For example, if a video is running in one application the system should now automatically reduce the volume of everything else and increase it when the video is finished.
Thread beginning with comment 388381
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Comment by supercompman
by supercompman on Thu 8th Oct 2009 19:57 UTC
Member since:

I've mentioned this before, but it's worth mentioning again: most of the problems that people have with pulse are configuration issues with the way distros ship.

I think pulse audio is a great thing... I just think most distros shipped it before they actually knew how to set it up properly.

Reply Score: 2

RE: Comment by supercompman
by segedunum on Fri 9th Oct 2009 01:31 in reply to "Comment by supercompman"
segedunum Member since:

PulseAudio should be able to be shipped with a default set of configuration settings and pretty much work by now. If it can't then there's something wrong.

The fact that Lennart feels the need to go into that much detail in that mail and that PulseAudio seems to be that finely balanced points to serious problems. I have never seen or heard of even something like JACK requiring that fine balancing act and the kind of latencies he's blaming on kernel configuration there sound way out of kilter and are completely unverifiable.

Reply Parent Score: 3

JACK != PulseAudio
by Tuxie on Fri 9th Oct 2009 08:22 in reply to "RE: Comment by supercompman"
Tuxie Member since:

Maybe because most people who use JACK use a custom compiled realtime-kernel and carefully selected, well supported audio hardware? Also, JACK is used with apps that have been carefully written to support it.

JACK has a very different feature set from PulseAudio. The overlap is pretty small. It's possible that they will "grow together" at one time in the future but that's not even on the roadmap today.

With PulseAudio, people use it with all kinds of cheap hardware with crappy ALSA drivers, badly coded, closed source software with all kinds of ugly hacks. When ANYTHING in the chain doesn't work properly, be it a stupid kernel configuration like Ubuntu's default one, missing features of the ALSA drivers, badly coded applications that does all kinds of tricks to bypass the proper, well emulated ALSA APIs, they blame it on PulseAudio. *sigh*

Reply Parent Score: 2