To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
You can argue sometimes corporations should be more important. Assuming a crime has been committed, then if the DA doesn't do anything, the area becomes less valuable as a place for companies to do business. You lose your one phone, but thousands lose income as businesses decide to move projects away or not start new business in the area due to their property not being protected. Why is your phone more important than thousands of families survival???
How is Apple above the law?? That would imply Apple committed a crime and were not prosecuted. Are you arguing that Apple directly told the DA what to do, and that Apple IS the government? Isn't it more likely that politically, there is pressure to keep the area friendly to high tech R&D? Isn't this the same area that has Intel, Google, and other major tech companies?
I understand your point, but I don't think your argument is true at all. Supposedly, Apple lost this phone. Someone picked it up. That would happen anywhere in the world. If someone had broken into Apple's buildings and stolen the phone, than this would be an entirely different matter.
Basically, it is obvious that the police should have been involved in this. But stealing computers just to "keep the area friendly to high tech R&D" is wrong, unless you can come up with a good reason as to why the police felt like they had to do that.
I don't think Zifre was saying Apple broke the law, rather that they have the power to use law enforcement for their own agendas. They in effect have created an upper class for themselves that can push law enforcement to do things for them that would not be done for the average citizen.
That position can easily be considered "above the law".
Apple didn't break the law. In fact, I think they are the most innocent. What Gizmodo did was not right, but what the police did was much worse.
Apple simply used its money and power to make the police do what they wanted. This is completely understandable (although this just decreases my already near 0 probability of buying Apple products). Apple is a corporation, and therefore, evil. The police are really at fault here, because they are supposed to do the right thing.





Member since:
2009-10-04
Actually it is discretionary. If someone stole my hypothetical phone that I built and programmed and blogged about it, the police would not go and break down their door. Only when you have a multi-billion dollar company will they do that.
Don't you think that individuals should be more important than corporations in the law?
Yes, but apparently Apple is.