Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 20th May 2010 09:08 UTC
Multimedia, AV Monty from Xiph.org Foundation, the people behind Theora and Vorbis, have announced their support for Google's WebM container format. "The Xiph.Org Foundation is pleased to announce its support of the WebM open media project as a project launch partner. As announced earlier today at the Google I/O Developer Conference, the WebM format combines the VP8 video codec, the Matroska container, and the Vorbis audio codec developed by Xiph into a high-quality, open, unencumbered format for video delivery on the Web. Xiph will continue to contribute to WebM as a whole and collaborate in its further development and deployment." Remember, people, without the hard work from the boys and girls at Xiph, Google would not have been able to do this.
Thread beginning with comment 425626
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE: I don't get it
by lemur2 on Thu 20th May 2010 12:32 UTC in reply to "I don't get it"
lemur2
Member since:
2007-02-17

I don't get what this means. Does it mean that they will focus on VP8 and theora development stops? Because I can't see any way they could keep developing both. Developing two competing codecs with the same goals really doesn't make sense to me.


Xiph aren't developing WebM, they are merely stating that they support what Google are trying to do with WebM.

Xiph's part in WebM is the audio codec for WebM, which is Vorbis.

It is unclear what Xiph will be doing, but I imagine that they might decide to continue development of Theora. Despite repeated and vocal claims to the contrary, Theora is actually pretty good. Theora 1.2 (still in development) promises to be very competitive indeed.

Wikipedia currently use Theora.

http://videoonwikipedia.org/

I'm not sure if Xiph or Wikipedia will continue with Theora or go with WebM instead. It might depend on Mozilla and Opera and their continued support for Theora as well as their announced support for WebM.

It seems to me that two open video codecs would be harder for patent trolls to attack than just one. If Theora development continues, it could provide open video with a "fallback" position perhaps.

The Open Video Alliance seems to be assuming that Theora will continue:
http://openvideoalliance.org/2010/05/google-frees-vp8-codec-for-htm...

What happens to Theora?

It’s possible that this decision by Google will create an environment where there are several popular video formats (as there are currently several popular image formats). Google, in fact, has advocated for Theora as an alternative codec for mobile devices, and recently funded research for native decoding on ARM processors. As with other web formats, choice and competition are good.

Wikipedia is currently the largest site currently serving Theora video. Wikimedia Foundation’s head of communications Jay Walsh has said that the site is open to hosting multiple video formats, just as it currently hosts multiple image formats. “Ultimately, this isn’t so much about switching formats as it is about making more options available for more web users,” he said to NewTeeVee.


Edited 2010-05-20 12:36 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 3