Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 7th Jul 2011 17:36 UTC, submitted by vivainio

Thread beginning with comment 480034
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Why? I mean, seriously, why?
Glitch-free audio and reduced power consumption. These are not "sophisticated audio capabilities", these are very basic requirements that a modern audio stack for desktops can't miss and Linux was missing.
Glitch-free audio and reduced power consumption. These are not "sophisticated audio capabilities", these are very basic requirements that a modern audio stack for desktops can't miss and Linux was missing.
I'll grant that glitch-free audio is a requirement for an audio stack, but every Linux box I ever used since '98 had that, with OSS and then ALSA—to the extent of the majority of normal desktops need: like I said, to play some audio files and maybe a nice beep for an error. I don't have any statistics, but I'd be very surprised if most people's usage strays far from that.
I definitely do not grant that reduced power consumption is a "very basic requirement"—all else being equal, it would be nice to have that too. But I'd much rather have an audio stack without it that works than one that uses no power at all since it isn't working.
Linux has had glitch free audio since 98? Really? Sure, the transition to PA was annoying as hell, but finally audio just works.
No more fighting the system to be able to have more than one application produce sound at a time.
No more stuttering when the system is under heavy load.
No more rebooting because a file handle didn't get freed up correctly, effectively locking the sound card.
For me, there has historically only been one subsystem more annoying than sound, and that is X, but that got to the "i dont need to think about it" stage way before the audio stack did.
Member since:
2005-07-08
Why? I mean, seriously, why?
Glitch-free audio and reduced power consumption. These are not "sophisticated audio capabilities", these are very basic requirements that a modern audio stack for desktops can't miss and Linux was missing.