Linked by Thom Holwerda on Fri 9th Dec 2011 23:41 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 499698
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[4]: the iPad design is over 100 years old.
by Alfman on Sat 10th Dec 2011 20:45
in reply to "RE[3]: the iPad design is over 100 years old."
RE[5]: the iPad design is over 100 years old.
by brichpmr on Sat 10th Dec 2011 23:02
in reply to "RE[4]: the iPad design is over 100 years old."
RE[4]: the iPad design is over 100 years old.
by Splinter on Sat 10th Dec 2011 20:52
in reply to "RE[3]: the iPad design is over 100 years old."
Again if Apple believed the "Market" will back them then why are the suing everyone. This belief that the "market" is magic and will do the right thing is absurd. Standard Oil, IBM, Bell and Microsoft are examples where the "market" failed to curb destructive company behaviors and the Law had to step in.
RE[4]: the iPad design is over 100 years old.
by _txf_ on Sat 10th Dec 2011 23:29
in reply to "RE[3]: the iPad design is over 100 years old."
If Apple's design claims are absurd, then the market will ultimately decide the issue. So far, the market thinks the iPad is pretty damn sweet.
The market has no bearing whatsoever on whether apples design patents are valid. The market thinks the ipad is pretty sweet for reasons completely orthogonal to the design patents claimed by apple...
Ignoring the total lack of logic in your comment, and just speculating on what you wrote, how would the market decide if the competitors are being sued out of existence?
RE[5]: the iPad design is over 100 years old.
by brichpmr on Sun 11th Dec 2011 12:41
in reply to "RE[4]: the iPad design is over 100 years old."
"If Apple's design claims are absurd, then the market will ultimately decide the issue. So far, the market thinks the iPad is pretty damn sweet.
The market has no bearing whatsoever on whether apples design patents are valid. The market thinks the ipad is pretty sweet for reasons completely orthogonal to the design patents claimed by apple...
Ignoring the total lack of logic in your comment, and just speculating on what you wrote, how would the market decide if the competitors are being sued out of existence? "
The market ALWAYS is the ultimate and final arbiter....judges come and go. If the iPad wasn't kicking butt and taking names, Samsung wouldn't be producing their arguably inferior clones.
RE[4]: the iPad design is over 100 years old.
by Bill Shooter of Bul on Mon 12th Dec 2011 16:15
in reply to "RE[3]: the iPad design is over 100 years old."




Member since:
2006-04-22
If Apple's design claims are absurd, then the market will ultimately decide the issue. So far, the market thinks the iPad is pretty damn sweet.