To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Do people REALLY need an "app" for everything now days, or is it something else?
I have actually done just that to compare the Google web maps with the new IOS6 Maps. In my experience, the new native Apple iteration has more fluid interface, just as good turn by turn directions and far superior and up to date satellite data for the locations I have tested. Now, I didn't have any dislike for the previous Google Map in IOS5, but the new app has excellent potential to blow Google out of the water, IMO.
Two reasons come to mind, how apps in general (I have no experience with iOS) could be superior or preferred to online access:
- Integration with the device hardware. GPS, compass, camera, etc.
- Functional without network connection.
Frankly, I don't think those are relevant for iOS. For one, google web page seems to have no problems with accessing native Location Services (if you allow it), and second - the maps app needs online connection to download maps on the fly, it always did.
See, that's what irks me about all those apps. Most of them do nothing that a web page can't do. Wikipedia app? It does the same thing as Wikipedia web page (and the page has a mobile layout already). IMDB app? Same thing. When I visit some web forum, it prompts me that there is an app for it. Why? What's the point? Why would I download an app when I already have the forum right in front of my eyes...
It may be true that there are thousands of apps in app store, but from what I found, most of them seem to be just front-ends for already available web services.





Member since:
2005-09-15
So... I'm not a heavy maps user so maybe I'm missing something important here, but what exactly is preventing people from bookmarking maps.google.com in mobile Safari and using that instead? It seems to offer about all the features that were previously available.
Do people REALLY need an "app" for everything now days, or is it something else?