Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 24th Feb 2014 11:13 UTC
PDAs, Cellphones, Wireless

Today, at Mobile World Congress, Nokia has unveiled its new line of smartphones: Nokia X. Instead of running Windows Phone or even Asha, these devices run Android, altered to look (somewhat) like Windows Phone. There's really not a whole lot of new stuff to say here, since most of it has already been leaked - except for the fact that there will be three Nokia X devices (with more to come!). The Nokia X, Nokia X+ (with slightly more memory), and the Nokia XL (with a larger display).

They look as colourful as any Nokia phone, but specifications are low-end; a dual-core 1Ghz processor, 800x480, and 512 or 768 MB RAM. It runs Android 4.1.2, and not the low-specifications optimised Android 4.4. It turns out that the low specifications impact the user experience, as evidenced by Tom Warren's first impressions:

Using the X can be quite frustrating, however, as the entire interface is prone to slow response and a lot of lag. Closing or switching between apps on the X takes far longer than other, even entry-level, smartphones, and browsing the web will quickly test your patience. The third-party apps we saw on the X, such as Facebook, looked as they do on other Android smartphones, but they too suffered from poor performance. Nokia's choice to combine the functions of home and back into the single back button is confusing, and i's difficult to predict exactly where in the interface the button will take you when you press it.

The user interface feels like Windows Phone, Android, and Harmattan had an illegitimate baby born out of wedlock. The end result is something that looks like a Frankenstein user interface, whose different aspects do not really align very well. The Metro-inspired homescreen, for instance, looks like a Windows Phone knock-off you would find on a cheap no-brand clone. The Android parts - inside applications, mostly - looks weird because Nokia's signature font simply doesn't fit.

I haven't used it, of course, so imagine a big asterisk here, but it looks like a classic example of design-by-committee. The Metro homescreen? Implemented because of Microsoft. The Nokia fonts? Implemented because Nokia. The swipe aspects? Because hey, the N9 is loved, so let's throw that in there as well. It doesn't feel like it has a unifying vision behind it.

The Nokia X looks like great hardware - as always, this is Nokia - but with a rather unusual and unappealing operating system. I honestly cannot wait until the XDA community gets its hands on this thing - I predict Google Play within a few days, and CyanogenMod within a few weeks. With this Android fork being completely void of Google services or Google applications, I would really wait until that's sorted out - unless you want to restrict yourself to a limited set of applications (developers need to port applications).

This raises the question of 'why'. Nokia now ships phones with four different operating systems - Windows Phone, Android, Series 40, Asha platform - which must be a hell to maintain. It doesn't really seem like Nokia needed to make an Android phone, considering that it already sells the 520 with Windows Phone. The only reason I can think of is that Nokia plans to eventually supplant Nokia Asha platform with this Android fork.

However, there's a problem here, and that's Microsoft's reaction to the Nokia X. Microsoft's Joe Belfiore:

We have a great relationship with Nokia. They've built great products. We haven't complete our acquisition. They may do some things we're excited about. Other things we are LESS excited. But whatever they do we are very supportive of the partnership.

That doesn't exactly instill confidence in the future of the Nokia X product line.

All in all, despite the somewhat shoddy first impressions of the user interface, and the warnings of slow performance, I'm still quite excited about the Nokia X. They look great, and once the XDA community gets its hands on it, it will actually become useful - because I saved the best for last: price. It'll be EUR 89 for the Nokia X, EUR 99 for the Nokia X+, and EUR 109 for the Nokia XL. To be honest, I think the X+ is the best deal, since the low resolution's pixelated edges of the 5" XL will most likely cut your eyeballs. Important note: it won't be available in the US.

That's a great price, and once CyanogenMod and other ROMs (4.4 instead of 4.1.2) run on it, it'll be useful too.

Thread beginning with comment 583455
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Bet won!
by Adurbe on Mon 24th Feb 2014 11:25 UTC
Adurbe
Member since:
2005-07-06

avgalen, I think its fair to say I took your bet and I won this one ;)

http://www.osnews.com/permalink?582726
(if anyone wants to take a bet, contact me. I am willing to bet they aren't going to release it and even that they aren't going to exhibit it)

For those who didn't know the stake was one vote up on a comment

Reply Score: 15

RE: Bet won!
by avgalen on Mon 24th Feb 2014 13:15 in reply to "Bet won!"
avgalen Member since:
2010-09-23

I tried to give you three because they actually announced 3 phones, but obviously OSNews doesn't allow more than 1 vote per comment per user.

I am still thinking that as soon as Nokia is finally bought by Microsoft this project gets killed.

Also, doesn't Nokia break just about every design/patent that Microsoft has on their Windows Phone UI? Of course I don't expect Microsoft to sue Nokia over this but it seems that Nokia did this while leaning on 2 ideas. "We are part of MS so we can do whatever we want with MS intellectual properties" and "We are independent so we can do whatever we want with the OS"

Anyway, congrats with winning this bet. Now do you want to bet if/when these phones will actually become real products as well (and real Microsoft Products)

Reply Parent Score: 8

RE[2]: Bet won!
by Adurbe on Mon 24th Feb 2014 13:40 in reply to "RE: Bet won!"
Adurbe Member since:
2005-07-06

haha double or nothing! Done ;)

---------

I think they will release them, but I doubt in the 'west', it will be delayed until its obsolete.

This phone is (to my mind) aimed squarely at the Indian sub-continent. They have the brand there and this is their last chance to capitalise on it before they 'lose' their hardware.

Nokia will really really push this range as I think Nokia will continue with their own app store/fork well after MS kill the Nokia X itself.

Nokia is in a unique position.
They have a 10 year cross licensing agreement with MS as part of the buy-out. This could mean their OEMs not having to pay the 'android tax'. $10 dollars per phone will soon add up for the mass production OEMs.

Microsoft would certainly support this endeavour, as it takes share from Google, the 'real enemy'. Maybe a Nokia store exclusive android MS Office to help the push ;)

p.s. I'm not breaking each of those down into bets :-p

Reply Parent Score: 6

RE[2]: Bet won!
by glarepate on Mon 24th Feb 2014 16:02 in reply to "RE: Bet won!"
glarepate Member since:
2006-01-04

I'll give you a +1 here so that I can still post comments later on.

But now I have to manually post all upvotes. (-:

Reply Parent Score: 3