While we at OSNews often talk about desktops, laptops, and netbooks, there is another “form factor” which is making inroads into various households: the home theatre PC, or HTPC. There are a lot of software packages out there that will aid in turning a computer into an HTPC, and since I’ve been testing three of them extensively over the past months, I figured we’d talk about what you use.
I started off with using the XBMC Media Center on a spare Pentium IV machine running Windows 7. The XBox Media Center was originally designed to run on the first XBox, but is now a multiplatform open source (GPL) HTPC platform, with a high degree of customisability and flexibility. The XBMC Media Center uses plugins written in Python, and these plugins can extend the functionality quite a bit, and because XBMX comes with lots of codecs built-in, there’s no need to download them separately.
While I really liked XBMC, I also found it a little too advanced for my taste. It can take quite a lot of work to add the functionality you need, and since it’s in constant flux, things might break. Still, the extensibility of XBMC is surely an advantage for many of you, but I personally prefer a more turn-key solution for my HTPC.
I since replaced the spare Pentium IV machine with a machine built specifically for HTPC computing: the silent Atom 330-based machine also used in my hackintosh guide. For this machine, I ditched XBMC in favour of Boxee. Technically – you’re not really ditching XMBC, as Boxee is a “distribution” of XBMC, but in a more turn-key fashion: lots of functionality comes out-of-the-box, such as downloadable subtitles, support for downloading metadata for TV shows/movies/etc., and so on. Boxee is big on the whole social media thing, integrating them into the application. This aspect of Boxee, to put it nicely, can bugger right off. I just gets in the way and serves no real purpose – for me, at least.
The interface is easy to use, and underneath it inherits all the advanced functionality of XBMC, so you can still get your geek on. I kind of see XBMC-plain as the Debian of the HTPC world, spawning off several off-shoots that deliver turn-key solutions. Another one of such solutions is Plex.
Unlike Boxee, Plex is Intel Mac only, and has no version available for Linux or Windows. I recently had to remove Windows 7 from my Atom 330 HTPC in order to see if I could get Snow Leopard installed (for a follow up to the hackintosh article). This process sadly failed, leaving me with a vanilla Leopard installation. This was the perfect opportunity to try out Plex.
I came away much impressed. Plex certainly has the best interface of the three; it sports the MediaStream theme which can also be installed on XBMC-plain. It’s slick, has lots of different views (from very detailed and useful to quite flashy and annoying), and most importantly, seems to have the better metadata download feature (although, for some odd reason, none of the three can download the metadata for season 5 of Two And A Half Men), and comes with additional goodies like playing the theme music of your TV shows while browsing them.
In the past, I also tried Windows Media Center (all versions) and Front Row, but I found them limited in functionality and often cumbersome to use. There are also various non-XBMC HTPC solutions out there that I’ve not yet had the opportunity to try, so feel free to tell us what solution you are using, and why.
I’ve used Windows Media Center a few times on my (now sold) laptop. I don’t use media center software in Linux or FreeBSD (just plain mplayer).
I’ve tried FrontRow on my iMac, but it does seem somewhat limited. Even with all possible codecs installed there are videos it won’t play well (or at all). I will surely try out Plex. Thanks!
Great solution. Works phenomenally well with Windows 7.
Linux + freevo.
OK, it is seems daunting and very german at first glance, but german C’t magazin a great distro since 2003(Docs in german though )
VDR ran on Pentium1 133Mhz, I think it is by far the oldest living room software.
With plugins it can do everything all those newbie progs do ( http://www.cadsoft.de/vdr/plugins.htm )
I really don’t know why it only seems to be popular in Germany .. I always wondered why people build living room PCs for MythTV, Freevo or XBMC. On the Xbox OK, but a PC can do so much more. No need to miss out on all the great features.
MythTV is good, the upcomming .22 release is shaping up.