As most of you will know, Nokia slapped Apple with a patent lawsuit last week. Nokia claims that Apple’s iPhone infringes upon 10 patents related to GSM, UMTS, and WiFi connectivity. In its SEC 10-K annual report filing, Apple made its first cautious response to Nokia’s claims.
Nokia claims that it has patent deals with about 40 other companies in the business for these exact same set of patents, which should add some weight to the Finnish phone maker’s claim. Nokia also states that it has made various offers to Apple about these patents, but that the Cupertino company rejected them all.
Still, with Nokia bleeding marketshare in the smartphone business to Apple’s iPhone, it does come across a little bit as “If you can’t beat them, sue them”.
In its SEC 10-K annual report filing, Apple has responded to Nokia’s claims. Even though the response to the claim is not yet due, Apple does state it does not intend to let this one go by.
The complaint alleges that these patents are essential to one or more of the GSM, UMTS and 802.11 wireless communications standards, and that the Company [Apple] has the right to license these patents from plaintiff [Nokia] on fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory terms and conditions. Plaintiff seeks unspecified FRAND compensation and other relief. The Company’s response to the complaint is not yet due. The Company intends to defend the case vigorously.
Well, this could turn out to be another long legal battle. Now, as you can see in the filing, a company of Apple’s size is involved in a lot of lawsuits – but a big one like this, between two heavyweights? Better get out the popcorn.
“We’ll defend the case vigorously” What does that mean?
Has anyone ever said ” We’ll defend limply?”
Does it mean our lawyers are taking Viagra? Quite a few years ago, a tech company screwed me and 30 other employees out of wages during a court-ordered interim receivership.
We tried to collect our wages through legal action; they responded that they were court-protected and that any action against them would be vigorously defended – with the money they weren’t paying us.
May those thieving accountants and their lying lawyers burn in hell and be sodomised for all eternity – vigorously.