Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 26th Oct 2006 17:10 UTC, submitted by M-Saunders
Databases "Yesterday Oracle announced the release of their own version of Red Hat Enterprise Linux, simply called Enterprise Linux or 'Unbreakable Linux'. In a remarkably similar move to such projects as CentOS, Oracle have decided to remove all Red Hat specific trademarks and brand it as their own (all quite legit, of course). They will be supplying bugfixes for this new version, and will also be synchronising it with future releases of Red Hat Enterprise Linux. We decided to take a peek at what Oracle had come up with. Read on for a first-look, and the Linux Format team's opinions." In the meantime, Mark Shuttleworth said a partnership with Oracle is no longer a matter of if, but when.
Thread beginning with comment 175680
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Boycott Oracle
by Don T. Bothers on Thu 26th Oct 2006 18:31 UTC
Don T. Bothers
Member since:
2006-03-15

Oracle is acting against the general goodwill of open source. They have way too much money to be doing this. I propose that any techhead out there considering a database for Linux only consider AIX, Sybase or PostgreSQL. Skip Oracle. A weak RedHat makes for a weak Linux. Last thing we want is IBM, Sun, HP and everyone else to have their version of Linux.

RE: Boycott Oracle
by Bit_Rapist on Thu 26th Oct 2006 18:38 in reply to "Boycott Oracle"
Bit_Rapist Member since:
2005-11-13

Oracle is acting against the general goodwill of open source.

Oracle is operating within the licensing rights granted in the GPL.

Last thing we want is IBM, Sun, HP and everyone else to have their version of Linux.

Who exactly is *we*?

So what if IBM, HP and everyone else under the sun releases a linux distro?

If the support is good and the price(s) are right then more power to them!

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 5

RE[2]: Boycott Oracle
by andrewg on Thu 26th Oct 2006 20:54 in reply to "RE: Boycott Oracle"
andrewg Member since:
2005-07-06

So what if IBM, HP and everyone else under the sun releases a linux distro?

If the support is good and the price(s) are right then more power to them!


Thats quite a short and narrow view. Redhat has proven to be an OSS advocate and has put a lot of their own resources into developing the 'Linux platform'. Oracle on the other hand may just take the money, which will likely be a net loss to Redhat, and not use it to develop the 'linux platform' in needed areas. Therefore 'ceteris paribus' the 'Linux platform' will have fewer resources developing it than if the money had gone to Redhat.

But there are a lot of factors and how it all ends up I don't pretend to know.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE[2]: Boycott Oracle
by ctl_alt_del on Thu 26th Oct 2006 18:52 in reply to "Boycott Oracle"
ctl_alt_del Member since:
2006-05-14

What a bunch of utter nonsense . . . .
Oracle is acting against the general goodwill of open source.
And what goodwill are they against?

They have way too much money to be doing this.
How does money factor into this?

I propose that any techhead out there considering a database for Linux only consider AIX, Sybase or PostgreSQL.
Good luck with that "AIX" database?!?

Last thing we want is IBM, Sun, HP and everyone else to have their version of Linux.
So what if they do, as long as they play by the GPL. Competition is good isn't it?

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 4

v RE: Boycott Oracle
by bryanv on Thu 26th Oct 2006 20:42 in reply to "Boycott Oracle"
RE: Boycott Oracle
by twenex on Thu 26th Oct 2006 21:42 in reply to "Boycott Oracle"
twenex Member since:
2006-04-21

If IBM, Sun, HP and everyone else has their own version of Linux, they may no longer see the need to preload Windows, or at least not on every PC.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE: Boycott Oracle
by Sphinx on Thu 26th Oct 2006 23:19 in reply to "Boycott Oracle"
Sphinx Member since:
2005-07-09

Want a Redhat only world? Boycotting Ubuntu for forking debian too? Xorg for XFree? Draw some kind of line somewhere?

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE: Boycott Oracle
by Sphinx on Thu 26th Oct 2006 23:23 in reply to "Boycott Oracle"
Sphinx Member since:
2005-07-09

any techhead out there considering a database for Linux only consider AIX, Sybase or PostgreSQL.

AIX is an operating system.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2