Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 3rd Sep 2009 12:31 UTC
Gnome Have you ever been bitten by accidentally loading multiple instances of the same application in GNOME? When you click on the launcher of an already-running application in GNOME, it will load up another instance of the same application, instead of switching to the already running one. This can lead to bugs and other unforeseen behaviour, which of course isn't desirable. In GNOME 3, this issue has been resolved.
Thread beginning with comment 382156
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
makes sense
by chekr on Thu 3rd Sep 2009 12:51 UTC
chekr
Member since:
2005-11-05

This makes a lot of sense...

The only thing is that with some apps it is desirable to open multiple windows (OOo, Firefox)...the user will have to use the file menu to open a new window. no big deal.

I think Gnome 3 is going to be a fantastic release with all of this polish being added. We are finally moving away from the windows UI model and creating our own distinct environment!

RE: makes sense
by righard on Thu 3rd Sep 2009 13:30 in reply to "makes sense"
righard Member since:
2007-12-26

Well I don't know, The only programme I know that behaves annoyingly is Thunderbird, when I open it when it is already open the newly open instance keeps saying it starting in the taskbar.

I do not want this feature, for example, if I want another terminal in another workspace (which happens allot!), now I just click the terminal icon in my panel, or press the keyboard shortcut. With this feature I'll have to,
1)click the terminal icon (which most probably switches to the workspace an instance in located.)
2)open a new window
3)switch the new window to the workspace I wanted it to be (which I have to remember)

This might not seem such a big problem, but considering how many times I need a quick terminal it can really mess up my work flow.

Edited 2009-09-03 13:31 UTC

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 6

RE: makes sense
by ParanoidAndroid on Thu 3rd Sep 2009 13:44 in reply to "makes sense"
ParanoidAndroid Member since:
2006-03-26

This does not make sense. I want to click on the terminal, or even better use a hotkey to get a second one. I don't want to press Menu -> New Window.

Once again, gnome tries to reinvent the wheel of usability, which is clearly a bad move.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 6

RE[2]: makes sense
by Steniko on Thu 3rd Sep 2009 14:44 in reply to "RE: makes sense"
Steniko Member since:
2008-04-21

I'm guessing they'll just do what Windows 7 does: middle click for a new window...

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE: makes sense
by Narishma on Thu 3rd Sep 2009 16:05 in reply to "makes sense"
Narishma Member since:
2005-07-06

And how will this be distinct? It will work exactly the same way as in Windows 7 or MacOSX. Previously it worked the same way as in previous versions of Windows.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 3

RE[2]: makes sense
by colinwalters on Thu 3rd Sep 2009 17:31 in reply to "RE: makes sense"
colinwalters Member since:
2007-11-02

Yes, my second sentence was:

"In this we'll be in good company with newer releases of other operating systems, but it's still a major change. What I want to explain in this blog entry is what that means from a user perspective."

Insert "GNOME" before "user" here; not all GNOME users/sysadmins/developers have used Windows 7 or OS X, and I wanted to explain the change to that audience. There are no plans to run out to patent it...

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE: makes sense
by OSGuy on Thu 3rd Sep 2009 21:50 in reply to "makes sense"
OSGuy Member since:
2006-01-01

The only thing is that with some apps it is desirable to open multiple windows (OOo, Firefox)...the user will have to use the file menu to open a new window. no big deal.

Hmm why the file menu? If one is trying to address an issue at least do it right:

- When a program is running and its icon is clicked from the task bar / launch bar, activate its window BUT when a program is running and an icon is clicked from the "Applications" menu, create another instance.

I think Gnome 3 is going to be a fantastic release with all of this polish being added. We are finally moving away from the windows UI model and creating our own distinct environment!

Hmm only time will tell...

Edited 2009-09-03 21:53 UTC

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2