Linked by lemur2 on Wed 9th Mar 2011 00:18 UTC
Multimedia, AV The WebM project Blog has announced an update release of the VP8 Codec SDK codenamed the "Bali" release. The Bali release was focused on making the encoder faster while continuing to improve its video quality.
Thread beginning with comment 465450
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
13.7% improvement, not 12.8%
by cjcoats on Wed 9th Mar 2011 16:19 UTC
cjcoats
Member since:
2006-04-16

Bogus algorithm for computing improvement in the
article: total improvement is multiplicative,
not additive

If the improvement from base to A is M% and from A
to B is N%, then we need to convert to improvement-
factors to do the computation.

A's improvement factor is 1 + M/100, and B's factor
is 1 + N/100, so the total improvement factor is
(1 + M/100)*(1 + N/100).

Converting that to percentages gives an incremental
improvement of 100*(1 + M/100)*(1 + N/100) - 1),
or M + N + M*N/100

If I read the individual numbers M,N correctly,
that gives a 13.7% improvement, not 12.8%.

Reply Score: 2

lemur2 Member since:
2007-02-17

Bogus algorithm for computing improvement in the article: total improvement is multiplicative, not additive If the improvement from base to A is M% and from A to B is N%, then we need to convert to improvement- factors to do the computation. A's improvement factor is 1 + M/100, and B's factor is 1 + N/100, so the total improvement factor is (1 + M/100)*(1 + N/100). Converting that to percentages gives an incremental improvement of 100*(1 + M/100)*(1 + N/100) - 1), or M + N + M*N/100 If I read the individual numbers M,N correctly, that gives a 13.7% improvement, not 12.8%.


A (Aylesbury) is (1+M%) * base
B (Bali) is (1+N%) * A

So, B is (1+N%) * (1+M%) * base

Bali: "Best" mode average quality improved 6.1% over Aylesbury using the SSIM metric.
Aylesbury: "Best" mode average quality improved 6.3% over launch release using the SSIM metric.

Total improvement from launch release to Bali release = 1.061 * 1.063 = 1.127843. I rounded this out to 12.8%.

Reply Parent Score: 2