Linked by Hadrien Grasland on Sat 25th Jun 2011 08:55 UTC, submitted by John
Mac OS X "Using a Mac may certainly be a safer choice for a lot of people as despite being vulnerable they are not targeted. However this is not the same as Macs being secure, something Eric Schmidt erroneously advised recently. I may be able to browse impervious to malware on a Mac at the moment, however I personally would not be comfortable using a platform so easily compromised if someone had the motivation to do so. In this article I address just why OS X is so insecure including the technical shortcomings of OS X as well as Apples policies as a company that contribute to the situation."
Thread beginning with comment 478628
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[3]: At least safer than
by Alfman on Sun 26th Jun 2011 04:32 UTC in reply to "RE[2]: At least safer than "
Member since:


"Sorry, Leap.A was at best (worst?) Malware. (not a worm or virus) "

Wasn't Leap.A this the virus which propagated through a jpeg decoder vulnerability? The executable payload was run whenever the remote user's thumbnail was displayed, at which point one's own jpeg thumbnail became infected. Why doesn't that qualify as a computer virus to you?

"This is the only example where you have a point and even this worm had flaws that made it highly unlikely to be seen in the wild."

It sounds funny to me to hear people downplay security vulnerabilities in this manor. If researchers successfully write a working proof of concept virus, but it is never released into the wild, then I'd still argue that it should still be considered evidence against a platform's security.

Look at recent security updates for OSX.

"Impact: Visiting a maliciously crafted website may lead to an unexpected application termination or arbitrary code execution"

This is one of many arbitrary code execution vulnerabilities mentioned. Hopefully this is fixed now, but I can guaranty that there was some mac chap somewhere boasting mac os as invulnerable, even though this was wrong. The lack real world attacks, if anything, demonstrates a lack of motivation.

No operating system has a perfect track record. Don't deny it, just fix it and move on.

Reply Parent Score: 3