Linked by David Adams on Wed 30th Nov 2011 20:18 UTC, submitted by Oren
PDAs, Cellphones, Wireless With WebOS out of the picture and the Blackberry Playbook as good as gone as well, we really only have iOS and Android left until Windows 8 comes out. I’ve finally gotten around to getting an Android device myself and spent the last week trying to see if my theoretical knowledge of the system and what I remember from the last Android device I had (which ran 1.6, viewed as ancient in Android land) fits reality. Read on for a full tear down and comparison on the two OSes.
Thread beginning with comment 498577
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
by Morgan on Thu 1st Dec 2011 12:34 UTC
Member since:

While I understand that the article is posted on a website called "Nothing But Tablets", I feel I must point out that Windows Phone 7 deserves mention even though it is restricted to phones right now.

From what I've seen of it on my new phone this past week, it is the most graceful and elegant phone OS I've ever used. I took a blind leap with it after constant frustration from Android and BlackBerry and I have zero regrets. It's the first time I have yet to be frustrated with a smartphone OS after a week's use, and I've used them all, with the exception of WebOS. From Palm Garnet to S60 to iOS to BlackBerry, WinMo to Android to Maemo, I have yet to find something I enjoy using as much as WP7 (though Maemo comes damn close).

If Windows 8 can improve upon WP7, I fail to see how it won't become Android's biggest competitor on touch devices, surpassing even iOS.

And the ultimate irony for me? This is the second time I've greatly enjoyed software from Microsoft, a company I loathe (Windows 7 is awesome!). Just like with Apple, I guess I can live with hating the company while enjoying their products. Call me a hypocrite, I don't care. (And I still won't buy Sony stuff, I guess I hate them the most).

Reply Score: 2

RE: Well...
by shmerl on Thu 1st Dec 2011 16:08 in reply to "Well..."
shmerl Member since:

Bloody diamonds?

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE[2]: Well...
by Morgan on Thu 1st Dec 2011 20:58 in reply to "RE: Well..."
Morgan Member since:

Well that's a bit melodramatic. To my knowledge none of the three companies I mentioned have killed anyone, though I believe some blame Apple for a factory worker's suicide a few years back.

My reasons for each differ, but all three companies have done things that pissed me off on a personal level in the past. I can tell you what I consider the worst for each:

Microsoft flexed their monopolistic muscle and convinced Compaq not to sell computers with BeOS, which helped to finish off the dying software company.

Apple has been using their patent portfolio to try to put other tablet makers out of business in Europe, since they can't get away with it here in the US. As far as I'm concerned it would be no different from trying to stop Dell or HP from making computers, or HTC and Motorola from making phones. Oh wait...

And as for Sony, well those bastards put Lik-Sang out of business overtly because they were selling Sony hardware without "permission", but it's an open secret they did it to stop Lik-Sang from selling Sega and Nintendo products, as they were a real threat to Sony's market share in Asia and Europe. That flies in the face of logic as Sony was making money off of Lik-Sang and their own executives in Europe enjoyed the fact that they could get Sony gear there when their own company prevented it otherwise.

Of course that wasn't my only reason for hating Sony; there's the rootkit debacle and the fact that for years they tried to cover up serious hardware issues with the Vaio laptop series. But the Lik-Sang deal personally affected me, as it was the only place I could find certain Sega products.

So, hardly a "blood diamond" situation on all counts, but I still have serious issues with each company. I know I don't have to justify my purchasing decisions, but in the case of Windows Phone 7, thanks to Microsoft's patent wizardry they would get more money from me if I bought an Android phone than a WP7 phone anyway, and I get a better interface with WP7.

As for Apple, I haven't bought anything new from the company since 2005 but there's no reason to give up what products I do still own and use. In fact, hanging on to this Mac mini I bought used in 2007 and my 2nd gen iPod shuffle prevents me from buying new products from them. Gotta love the fact that their own high product quality and lasting value actually prevents sales! ;)

Reply Parent Score: 2