Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 19th Apr 2017 20:54 UTC
Android

I challenge anyone to receive a notification on Samsung s Galaxy S8 and not be charmed by the elegant blue pulse of light that traces the contours of the phone's gorgeous screen. This sort of subtlety, this sort of organic, emotive, instant appeal is not something I ever expected Samsung would be capable of. But the company once judged to have cynically copied Apple's iPhone design has exceeded all expectations this year: the 2017 version of Samsung's TouchWiz brings its software design right up to the high standard of its hardware.

I have always hated TouchWiz. It was ugly, overbearing, complex, and annoying.

Keyword here is was. As per my philosophy to never rot stuck in a single brand or platform, I replaced my Nexus 6P with a Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge a few weeks ago. I was assuming I'd have to root it and install a custom ROM on it within days, so I had the proper files and reading material ready to go the day the phone arrived.

But as I was using the phone for a few days, it dawned on my that TouchWiz on the S7 Edge was... Not that bad. I buy off-contract, so I didn't get any carrier crapware (as far as I know, Dutch carriers don't really do crapware to begin with), and even Samsung's own stuff was remarkably sparse, and you could hide most of Samsung's stuff anyway. I was pleasantly surprised.

I was even more pleasantly surprised when it dawned on me that several parts of TouchWiz were superior to Google's stock Android versions. The stock Android alarm/clock application is a UI disaster, but the TouchWiz version is clean, simple, and much easier to use. TouchWiz' contacts application, too, sports a cleaner look and I find it easier to use than the stock version. Most of all, though, Samsung's settings application is so much better than the stock Android one in terms of looks, organisation, search capabilities, and so on, that I'm surprised Google hasn't copied it outright.

Within just a few days, I thought to myself "...okay right so that's why Samsung dominates Android and has 80% smartphone market share in The Netherlands". Samsung has truly cleaned up TouchWiz, and I'm curious to see if I hit that thing everybody is talking about where Samsung phones get slower over time, something that didn't happen to my Nexus devices.

CGP Grey once said, in one of his videos:

The trick is to keep your identity separate from your opinions. They're objects in a box you carry with you, and should be easily replaceable if it turns out they're no good. If you think that the opinions in the box are "who you are", then you'll cling to them despite any evidence to the contrary.

Bottom line: if you always want to be right, you need to always be prepared to change your mind.

I try to apply this as much as possible, including here on OSNews. Any longterm reader of this site knows I haven't been kind to TouchWiz over the years. A few weeks with a modern Samsung phone has completely changed my mind.

Thread beginning with comment 643233
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[5]: That's funny
by Troels on Thu 20th Apr 2017 14:14 UTC in reply to "RE[4]: That's funny"
Troels
Member since:
2005-07-11

That particular device is a Nexus 7 2012, and the notification is for Android 5 which makes it unusably slow. I'll keep it on Android 4 thank you.


So ancient tablet running a very old Android version, nice, i am ready to discuss iOS then based on my iPhone 4 that i have home in a drawer, kept on version 6 as 7 was too ugly for me to handle just before retiring it...

Overnight on said nexus ;)


So you put 3 million apps on it ;)

Reply Parent Score: 3

RE[6]: That's funny
by torp on Thu 20th Apr 2017 16:16 in reply to "RE[5]: That's funny"
torp Member since:
2010-08-10

"That particular device is a Nexus 7 2012, and the notification is for Android 5 which makes it unusably slow. I'll keep it on Android 4 thank you.


So ancient tablet running a very old Android version, nice, i am ready to discuss iOS then based on my iPhone 4 that i have home in a drawer, kept on version 6 as 7 was too ugly for me to handle just before retiring it...
"

Well, my point is that, as a user, I stopped caring what Google does with Android. Apple would have to piss me off too much to reconsider. Probably my mistake was to play the early adopter, my first smartphone was a Samsung and was running Android 1.6 ;) Back then TouchWiz was bad. Really bad.

If it makes you feel any better, I also have Android 5 and 6 on my desk... it looks cluttered and i can't shake the feeling that google is TRYING TO CRAM EVERY SERVICE THEY CAN THINK OF DOWN MY THROAT.

"Overnight on said nexus ;)


So you put 3 million apps on it ;)
"
Afraid not - just whatever Google decided to force install, plus whatever i work on which doesn't auto update yet because it's not in the app store.

Reply Parent Score: 2