Most of us here are not particularly big fans of the concept of patents. Most of us are aware of the significance of patents, we just believe the system has gone out of control and needs a serious kick in the butt. Well, it turns out not even the richest people on this earth are immune to the call of the patent troll. Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen has filed a massive patent lawsuit, using broad and vague patents to sue just about any big name in the business – from Apple to Google.
Paul Allen left Microsoft in 1983, although he remains a major investor in the software giant. After leaving Microsoft, Allen undertook several business ventures, some of which crashed and burned pretty badly. Recently, Allen was one of the billionaires who, alongside Bill Gates, donated half of their fortune to charity.
The patents in this particular case were granted to Interval Research Corp., Allen’s research laboratory in Palo Alto which went bankrupt. Interval Research was actually a real research laboratory, employing people like Robert Shaw, Max Mathews, and David Reed, one of the people behind TCP/IP. The company worked on technology Allen wanted to use for other ventures.
In any case, what remains of the company is a shell, with the clear stench of patent troll around it. Using four extremely vague (and dare I say it, obvious) patents, the company is suing (breathe): Apple, Google, AOL, Facebook, ebay, Netflix, Office Depot, OfficeMax, Staples, Yahoo, and YouTube. Ominously missing are Microsoft and Amazon.
The patents in question are summarised perfectly by Ars. “The patents revolve around three main concepts: browser use for navigating through information, managing a user’s peripheral attention while using a device, and alerting users to items of current interest,” Ars’ Jacqui Cheng details, “They collectively address the general concept of presenting searched-for information to a user along with related news articles, media (such as music or videos), status updates from friends, or data (such as stock or weather info).”
Allen himself didn’t say anything about the case, but his spokesperson did. “Paul thinks this is important, not just to him but to the researchers at Interval who created this technology,” said the spokesman, David Postman, “We recognize that innovation has a value, and patents are the way to protect that.”
Google responded to the lawsuit by telling Ars Technica that this lawsuit is nothing but abuse of the patent system. “This lawsuit against some of America’s most innovative companies reflects an unfortunate trend of people trying to compete in the courtroom instead of the marketplace,” the Google spokesperson told Ars, “Innovation – not litigation – is the way to bring to market the kinds of products and services that benefit millions of people around the world.”
Well, it’s not as if Silicon Valley’s finest aren’t fascinated by patent lawsuits themselves, so I can hardly feel particularly sorry for them. With the enormous influence these large companies have, they could’ve done something about this already. The truth is, of course, that the likes of Google and Apple benefit greatly from the utterly broken US patent system and the completely incompetent USPTO.
Cry me a river. Let these idiots sue each other straight to hell.
There is now a third thing to be sure of in this life besides “death” and “taxes” …Thing #3, the computer and technology industry will never have a single day of the year without some ongoing lawsuit. if you used half as much money as your spending on court fees in R&D you’d have the potential to have made a product that could carry your company into the future, instead of attempting to leverage something so far from the past and patent troll the hell out of the industry… this mind set has to change people…
Is it just me or are we seeing more software patent suits than ever these days? Its been a common saying that everybody is violating everybody elses patents, the patent office will grant pretty much anything that uses words they don’t understand. But for a while at least it seemed that everybody was locked into a patent cold war where the patents are the nukes and if everybody actually enforced everything they had a claim to the result would be MAD. But now that has changed and everybody is suing everybody. The is going to get very ugly before people come to their senses and fix the damn patent problem.