Linked by Thom Holwerda on Tue 18th Sep 2007 19:52 UTC, submitted by Hendra
Thread beginning with comment 272417
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
The difference between 3 and 4 cores for the average user would be negligible at best.
While this is true for the average user, this is an ideal solution for the cost-sensitive software developer.
With two cores it is relatively easy for a developer to implement a concurrent algorithm that works correctly for two concurrent threads, yet fails miserably for three or more. In contrast, however, those algorithms which work for correctly for three threads almost always (a) work for any number of threads (subject to performance scalability issues), or (b) appear on their face to be specifically limited in the number of concurrent threads which are correctly supported.
With three cores, a developer will be able, much more efficiently, to catch and repair such errors before release. Once such machines are released, I would expect them to be targeted towards developers writing concurrent software.
RE[2]: It's a smart idea.
by phoudoin on Wed 19th Sep 2007 12:21
in reply to "RE: It's a smart idea."
With two cores it is relatively easy for a developer to implement a concurrent algorithm that works correctly for two concurrent threads, yet fails miserably for three or more. In contrast, however, those algorithms which work for correctly for three threads almost always (a) work for any number of threads (subject to performance scalability issues), or (b) appear on their face to be specifically limited in the number of concurrent threads which are correctly supported.
Agreed.
Now the cost effectiveness for the customer of a 3 cores CPU vs a 4 cores remains to be seen, as we don't know yet how AMD will price this Phenom X3 and how it will compare with a Core2 Q6600 for example, which seem to be the best-seller Quad CPU this summer...
No doubt that the cost effectiveness for AMD of this Phenom X3 is real: X4 wafers cost will drop.





Member since:
2006-01-02
They can get better processor yields then by simply disabling silicon with busted cores on it.
Either way, this whole core madness is crazy. The difference between 3 and 4 cores for the average user would be negligible at best.