Surface Pro reviews are in

And there we are – the Surface Pro reviews are in. Reading through them all, there’s clearly a common theme, and it’s not particularly positive. We’re a few months in now, so I think we can finally call it: Windows 8 and Surface are the wrong way to go.

The Surface Pro reviews all share a common theme: for a machine that’s not supposed to have any compromises, it sure sports a lot of compromises. Battery life is atrocious, the split personality between Metro and the desktop is as jarring as ever, touch on the desktop is cumbersome, the desktop is set to 150% scaling which looks weird, it’s heavy, the kickstand only has one position so it’s not fun as a laptop, and so on, and so forth.

The end result is that it’s not a good laptop, and not a good tablet. In other words, the idea that Surface is a ‘no compromises’ device is a bunch of nonsense. If you want a laptop, you’re better off buying something like a MacBook Air or an Aspire S7, and if you want a tablet you’re better off with an iPad or a Nexus.

All this has solidified my belief that Windows 8, as it stands now, was the wrong way to go. Microsoft should have released Windows 8 without Metro, and used Windows Phone 8 for tablets and phones. Windows Phone 8 already has many decent applications, developers are familiar with it, and the interface was already there – and a far less confusing one, too. I see very little in Windows 8’s Metro that Windows Phone didn’t already have or that could not be added without breaking anything.

On top of that, it would’ve solved the 7″-problem. You may have noticed there’s no 7″ Windows 8 tablet, and there’s good reason for that: Metro is not suited for it, the desktop is not suited for it. It’s pretty clear the major design decisions for Windows 8 were finalised before the popularity of 7″ tablets became clear, and so Microsoft has to address it afterwards.

Microsoft could have entered the hardware space with a beautifully simple range of devices – Surface 4, Surface 7, Surface 10 (running Windows Metro, all ARM), and an ultrabook with a Surface-like design (Windows 8 without Metro, x86). Instead, we have lacklustre Surface tablets, a confusing operating system with split-personality disorder, and a development story that’s anything but consistent across devices.

With Nokia barely being able to sell any serious amount of Lumias and Surface’s lukewarm reception, Microsoft is certainly going through a tough time. I applaud Microsoft for trying to be different and having something resembling a vision, but its execution needs a lot of work.

100 Comments

  1. chekr 2013-02-06 11:50 am EST
    • kragil 2013-02-06 12:04 pm EST
      • chekr 2013-02-06 1:10 pm EST
        • Priest 2013-02-07 5:26 am EST
          • kaiwai 2013-02-09 4:01 pm EST
          • nej_simon 2013-02-10 12:46 pm EST
      • bassbeast 2013-02-11 3:39 am EST
        • zima 2013-02-13 8:34 pm EST
    • ichi 2013-02-06 3:01 pm EST
    • ze_jerkface 2013-02-06 7:26 pm EST
    • grat 2013-02-07 3:46 pm EST
    • boldingd 2013-02-11 5:09 pm EST
  2. ephracis 2013-02-06 11:58 am EST
    • bnolsen 2013-02-06 1:39 pm EST
      • ephracis 2013-02-06 2:09 pm EST
        • Nelson 2013-02-07 3:34 am EST
        • cdude 2013-02-07 11:33 am EST
      • bert64 2013-02-07 3:59 pm EST
    • ilovebeer 2013-02-06 6:37 pm EST
      • ze_jerkface 2013-02-06 7:33 pm EST
      • Delgarde 2013-02-07 1:44 am EST
        • ilovebeer 2013-02-07 4:30 pm EST
    • miguelholandes 2013-02-08 2:11 pm EST
      • _txf_ 2013-02-08 4:40 pm EST
      • ephracis 2013-02-09 10:42 am EST
  3. Lava_Croft 2013-02-06 12:22 pm EST
    • _cynic_ 2013-02-06 12:32 pm EST
      • marcus0263 2013-02-06 10:29 pm EST
    • Soulbender 2013-02-07 3:08 am EST
      • cdude 2013-02-07 11:50 am EST
      • marcus0263 2013-02-07 7:28 pm EST
  4. ronaldst 2013-02-06 12:51 pm EST
    • lindkvis 2013-02-06 3:17 pm EST
      • JPisini 2013-02-06 7:56 pm EST
    • WereCatf 2013-02-06 4:11 pm EST
    • ze_jerkface 2013-02-06 7:48 pm EST
      • Nelson 2013-02-07 2:19 am EST
        • aaronb 2013-02-08 8:42 am EST
      • Tuishimi 2013-02-07 3:55 pm EST
      • -pekr- 2013-02-08 5:53 am EST
        • Soulbender 2013-02-08 6:16 am EST
    • dsmogor 2013-02-06 8:37 pm EST
      • sonnyrao 2013-02-10 8:44 am EST
    • Vanders 2013-02-06 11:49 pm EST
      • Nelson 2013-02-07 3:32 am EST
    • mikebelle 2013-02-07 5:23 pm EST
  5. Nelson 2013-02-06 1:13 pm EST
    • jared_wilkes 2013-02-06 4:13 pm EST
      • Nelson 2013-02-06 4:42 pm EST
        • ze_jerkface 2013-02-06 8:05 pm EST
          • Nelson 2013-02-07 2:17 am EST
        • jared_wilkes 2013-02-07 5:18 am EST
    • galvanash 2013-02-06 4:47 pm EST
      • WereCatf 2013-02-06 4:52 pm EST
        • galvanash 2013-02-06 5:36 pm EST
      • Nelson 2013-02-06 7:05 pm EST
        • sonnyrao 2013-02-10 8:48 am EST
  6. bnolsen 2013-02-06 1:46 pm EST
  7. earksiinni 2013-02-06 1:55 pm EST
    • BushLin 2013-02-06 8:25 pm EST
    • _txf_ 2013-02-06 8:51 pm EST
      • cdude 2013-02-07 12:08 pm EST
    • phoenix 2013-02-07 3:13 am EST
      • Laurence 2013-02-07 11:44 am EST
        • phoenix 2013-02-07 7:21 pm EST
  8. Adurbe 2013-02-06 2:52 pm EST
  9. gsyoungblood 2013-02-06 4:19 pm EST
    • dvhh 2013-02-06 11:27 pm EST
  10. snip3rm00n 2013-02-06 5:02 pm EST
  11. runjorel 2013-02-06 5:56 pm EST
  12. Luminair 2013-02-06 7:40 pm EST
  13. ze_jerkface 2013-02-06 7:58 pm EST
  14. ezraz 2013-02-06 8:26 pm EST
  15. leos 2013-02-06 9:33 pm EST
  16. miguelholandes 2013-02-07 12:45 am EST
    • tylerdurden 2013-02-07 1:25 am EST
    • unheeding 2013-02-08 3:51 am EST
      • miguelholandes 2013-02-08 2:43 pm EST
        • r_a_trip 2013-02-11 10:42 am EST
  17. bram 2013-02-07 1:11 am EST
    • Nelson 2013-02-07 6:15 am EST
    • lucas_maximus 2013-02-07 10:22 am EST
      • cdude 2013-02-07 12:17 pm EST
        • lucas_maximus 2013-02-07 12:49 pm EST
          • REM2000 2013-02-07 2:12 pm EST
          • lucas_maximus 2013-02-07 3:03 pm EST
          • darknexus 2013-02-07 3:51 pm EST
          • lucas_maximus 2013-02-07 6:24 pm EST
    • darknexus 2013-02-07 3:53 pm EST
      • lucas_maximus 2013-02-07 6:25 pm EST
      • bert64 2013-02-08 9:09 am EST
  18. abdavidson 2013-02-08 2:13 am EST
  19. graig 2013-02-08 2:51 am EST
  20. kurkosdr 2013-02-08 3:26 pm EST
  21. Moochman 2013-02-08 4:27 pm EST
  22. modicr 2013-02-08 6:36 pm EST
  23. PieterGen 2013-02-10 6:30 pm EST
    • zima 2013-02-12 6:35 pm EST
  24. truckweb 2013-02-11 5:38 pm EST
    • Jokel 2013-02-11 10:36 pm EST