Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 20th Feb 2008 20:20 UTC
Windows Microsoft has flung open the door for anyone interested in getting their mitts on release candidate 2 of Windows XP SP3. The software giant had made RC2 of the final service pack of XP already available to several thousand beta testers a few weeks ago. Now, it feels brave enough to pump it out to the masses.
Order by: Score:
Methinks I'll wait
by Jon Dough (3.16) on Wed 20th Feb 2008 22:28 UTC
Jon Dough
Member since:
2005-11-30
Fans: 1

Shrug. I think I'll wait until it appears in Windows Update. Not that I am aware of any problems with SP3; I am just not aware of any urgent need to update with something other than final production code. Yes, an RC is very close to final production code, but it can theoretically still change.

RE: Methinks I'll wait
by RGCook (4.44) on Wed 20th Feb 2008 22:36 UTC in reply to "Methinks I'll wait"
RGCook Member since:
2005-07-12
Fans: 0

I agree. I'm also thinking it might be a good time to update a slipstreamed disk, pull out the old cpu and blow the dust out of old Bess...give her a shot of adrenaline via a faster cpu off newegg and then install fresh.

Hopefully, that will tide me over until Windows 7 finally comes out.

How many are out there like me in a holding pattern regarding upgrading until Vista is a memory?

RE[2]: Methinks I'll wait
by Phloptical (3.48) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 00:13 UTC in reply to "RE: Methinks I'll wait"
Phloptical Member since:
2006-10-10
Fans: 1

I'm praying for the day when I can wake up and not see Windows Vista on the shelves.

RE[2]: Methinks I'll wait
by vimh (3) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 00:44 UTC in reply to "RE: Methinks I'll wait"
vimh Member since:
2006-02-04
Fans: 2

"How many are out there like me in a holding pattern regarding upgrading until Vista is a memory?"

You're making the assumption that Windows 7 will be an improvement.

RE[3]: Methinks I'll wait
by camo (1.68) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 02:35 UTC in reply to "RE[2]: Methinks I'll wait"
camo Member since:
2007-10-08
Fans: 1

You're making the assumption that Windows 7 will be an improvement.


I sure hope it is. How would MS deal with another release that gets the same(bad)press as Vista has. Might be a good time to buy shares in MS though.

RE[3]: Methinks I'll wait
by Sabz (1.32) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 07:22 UTC in reply to "RE[2]: Methinks I'll wait"
Sabz Member since:
2005-07-07
Fans: 0

"How many are out there like me in a holding pattern regarding upgrading until Vista is a memory?"

You're making the assumption that Windows 7 will be an improvement.

it'll have to be an improvement over Vista if MS wanna remain in business,

RE: Methinks I'll wait
by chrono13 (4.88) on Wed 20th Feb 2008 22:46 UTC in reply to "Methinks I'll wait"
chrono13 Member since:
2006-10-25
Fans: 1

"Yes, an RC is very close to final production code, but it can theoretically still change."


Unfortunately, with Microsoft you have to shift all development cycles one step to the right, with RC falling right off the track altogether.

"Release Candidates" are released with the foreknowledge that there are still bugs to be fixed, and there will be code changes. An example was RC2, where the build number is placed in the My Computer's properties instead of "Service Pack 3".

This isn't just with their Service Packs either. This "release an RC as a beta" applies to almost all of their software. Then they change the code, and release the final without a real RC. The release candidate is the one you buy.

This shift unfortunately extends backward. Beta's are often very clearly alphas. Most of the software world uses RC to mean "Candidate for Release", and potentially, hopefully, no code changes.

Perhaps this is one of the primary causes of the release buggy, fix later problem* that Microsoft has fallen in to.

*Not really a business problem for a monopoly, as there is no need to compete.

So when is this thing going gold?
by WorknMan (3.64) on Wed 20th Feb 2008 22:50 UTC
WorknMan
Member since:
2005-11-13
Fans: 3

A friend's computer has been running on an XP install that I did about 2 and a half years ago (so much for having to reinstall Windows every 6 months, eh?), and now it is starting to implode. I need to do a clean install of that machine soon... I'm hoping to wait until SP3 hits so I can slipstream it. You guys think it'll take them much longer than a month to release the gold code?

RE: So when is this thing going gold?
by chrono13 (4.88) on Wed 20th Feb 2008 23:04 UTC in reply to "So when is this thing going gold?"
chrono13 Member since:
2006-10-25
Fans: 1

Despite my above comment, seeing that this is a rollup (including some patches you had to request prior), it seemed reasonably safe, especially compared to the alternative. And getting all those bug fixes is reason enough. If it fixes 100 bugs and creates two - the tradoff may be worth it.

Anecdotal, I know, but I have not had any issues with RC2, except that certain things will no longer show up in Windows update after you apply SP3 (IE7, WMP11, etc). But they can be installed by downloading them and I have not seen any issues with this (this applies to my virtual machines of Windows in Linux).

Another gentleman I know who installed it had to uninstall IE7 to get IE working, albiet as IE6, but then could not install IE7 again, but I believe his was not a clean install. YMMV.

Windows E.O.L.
by uproot (2.76) on Wed 20th Feb 2008 23:03 UTC
uproot
Member since:
2006-10-05
Fans: 0

As i understand it XP will be "supported" until April 2009. Does this mean no more security fixes or just no new tech updates? both?

I would like to buy XP sp3 but not if its only good for a year.

RE: Windows E.O.L.
by chrono13 (4.88) on Wed 20th Feb 2008 23:07 UTC in reply to "Windows E.O.L."
chrono13 Member since:
2006-10-25
Fans: 1

Windows XP Professional Released: 12/31/2001 Mainstream support retired: 4/14/2009 Extended support retired: 4/8/2014

They will stop main support after 4.09, but will generally fix major security flaws up to 4.14

Not Getting Vista. No Faith in 7 Either
by BrendaEM (1.48) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 00:17 UTC
BrendaEM
Member since:
2005-11-23
Fans: 0

I don't see me getting Vista any time soon.

I am still running XP on my Thinkpad 61P until things become a little more settled with the graphic hardware. Though, after running Ubuntu, XP looks dated. NTFS, needs frequent defraging when I'm moving a lot files around.

To avoid lock-in, I use mostly cross-platform programs. Doing grahics, the hold-outs are Photoshop, which Google may help with Wine now, and Rhino3d, which might be running on the Mac soon.

Honestly, when I look my OS situation, Window is not seeming very compelling. Its not Vista's hardware requirements, it's that they dared use all a computers assets, and provide what benefit? Do programs run as fast? Vista treats memory like someone else is paying for it, which might not be an issue now, but when 7 comes out the requirements will probably be higher too.

Vista is a DRM operating system, that's supposed to make its vendors feel safe, but now they are leaving in droves. Cheers!

v Who cares...
by TrendKill (1.08) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 00:28 UTC
Windows XP
by RHCE07 (1.68) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 00:46 UTC
RHCE07
Member since:
2007-12-08
Fans: 0

Am I correct in saying you cannot buy a new
machine pre-loaded with XP?

RE: Windows XP
by stodge (2) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 01:49 UTC in reply to "Windows XP"
stodge Member since:
2005-09-08
Fans: 1

I think I read that some companies reverted to pre-installing XP. I could be wrong though.

RE: Windows XP
by Jon Dough (3.16) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 02:08 UTC in reply to "Windows XP"
Jon Dough Member since:
2005-11-30
Fans: 1

Am I correct in saying you cannot buy a new
machine pre-loaded with XP?


Dell, amongst others, is selling new PC's with XP installed. Though I don't think you'll be seeing XP on any computers you can buy off-the-shelf at your local Best Buy, Office Depot, etc.

RE: Windows XP
by orfanum (2.84) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 07:45 UTC in reply to "Windows XP"
orfanum Member since:
2006-06-02
Fans: 1

It does not appear to be easy. At the beginning of this year I understood that the cut-off point for supplying machines preloaded with XP was 31 Jan. I was angling to get an HP or Toshiba laptop since after some research these companies *appeared* to hold out the most sraightforward downgrade/XP supply options, sometimes depending on model. However, I was informed by a reliable tech (who I have been using for some years) for example that the HP XP downgrade download had 'just disappeared' from the HP site in the UK. This was around mid-January.

Trying various outlets was like hitting your head against the proverbial brick wall - Couldn't get an off-the-shelf machine with XP, and I was told categorically in various laces (cough PC World, Dixon's cough) that were I to load XP myself I would void my warranty, etc. Very unhelpful.

So, now (despite previous posts to the contrary) I am currently a Vista user...I went with the Toshiba in the end though since they very usefully still supply XP drivers (at least for the model I got). I am now poised with a slipstreamed XP install, with Toshiba's driver base, to go XP and Linux.

But Vista's eye-candy is like the Voice of Saruman...Got to summon up enough plain Hobbit courage and common sense to resist...(just a bit of hairy-footed humour)...

Edited - It strikes me I may get some feedback along the lines of 'why didn't you just get a laptop without an OS'? Just to say, for information, I tried this option, but even with the Vista tax, the hardware specs I got on this machine surpassed anything I could expect from going down that route, unfortunately, although the process did throw up some interesting small-scale suppliers.

Edited 2008-02-21 07:52 UTC

RE: Windows XP
by bornagainenguin (2.6) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 13:54 UTC in reply to "Windows XP"
bornagainenguin Member since:
2005-08-07
Fans: 5

Am I correct in saying you cannot buy a new
machine pre-loaded with XP?


That is incorrect. Dell is still allowing you to "customize with Windows XP" on its machines.

--bornagainpenguin

RE[2]: Windows XP
by Bobthearch (2.08) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 22:10 UTC in reply to "RE: Windows XP"
Bobthearch Member since:
2006-01-27
Fans: 0

Is that available on all of their computers? When I checked a while back, it seemed Dell was only offering XP on a select few systems.

Good news
by camo (1.68) on Thu 21st Feb 2008 02:24 UTC
camo
Member since:
2007-10-08
Fans: 1

I'm still surprised that we are getting SP3 at all. I thought MS would just string us out until after mainstream support ended then cancel it.

This is good news though. Hopefully we don't have to wait too much longer for the final version.

Couldn't wait
by ignw (1) on Fri 22nd Feb 2008 08:21 UTC
ignw
Member since:
2008-02-22
Fans: 0

I'd prefer to wait the release come.

Regards,
wir

http://knows-windows.blogspot.com/