Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 28th Sep 2005 11:04 UTC, submitted by Rahul
Red Hat Red Hat, with help from IBM and Trusted Computing Solutions, plans to put its operating system through the paces of the National Information Assurance Partnership's Common Criteria evaluation program to create the first "trusted" Linux operating system.
Order by: Score:
The article is wrong and ...
by Robert Escue on Wed 28th Sep 2005 13:11 UTC
Robert Escue
Member since:
2005-07-08

First, there is Trusted Solaris for x86:

http://www.sun.com/software/solaris/trustedsolaris/

And does RedHat intend to certify a GUI as trusted, since Trusted Solaris has Common Desktop Environment certified as Trusted, or is it CLI only?

Reply Score: 1

RE: The article is wrong and ...
by Rahul on Wed 28th Sep 2005 13:42 UTC in reply to "The article is wrong and ..."
Rahul Member since:
2005-07-06

Not sure what you consider wrong in the article since it mentions that in the "past' used to run only on RISC architectures.

An updated version of RHEL 4 targets EAL4 while ongoing efforts in RHEL 5 target the LSPP, CAPP and RBAC profiles which I believe dont include the GUI in a comprehesive way beyond potential visual display of current roles,labels or profile including printing

http://niap.nist.gov/cc-scheme/in_evaluation.html#r
https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-lspp

There are independant efforts to do this however that is not tied to the certification process

http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/FC5Future

Hope that helps

Reply Score: 1

Robert Escue Member since:
2005-07-08

My bad.

Reply Score: 1

RE: The article is wrong and ...
by Anonymous on Wed 28th Sep 2005 13:47 UTC in reply to "The article is wrong and ..."
Anonymous Member since:
---

From TFA: "The big thing here is that it makes Red Hat Enterprise Linux 5 the only other trusted operating system in the world, beyond Trusted Solaris," says Ed Hammersla, chief operating officer of Trusted Computer Solutions, a provider of security software and services. "It's a big milestone in the maturity of Linux."

Even the article blurb doesn't say first "trusted" operating system, but rather first "trusted" linux operating system.

The article is correct.

Reply Score: 0

Anonymous Member since:
---

The article is still wrong. BAE Systems has the XTS-400 which is a trusted platform (OS and hardware), at EAL-5. RHEL and Solaris are therefore not the only trusted OSs.

Reply Score: 1

Robert Escue Member since:
2005-07-08

Forgot about that one!

Reply Score: 1

Anonymous Member since:
---

It's even worse than that as SuSE has had EAL 4+ certification for at least 18 months, so the article is worse than just wrong....

Chris.

Reply Score: 0

Anonymous Member since:
---

First
SUSE Enterprise 9 was released around Aug 2004, so 18 months is a bit of a stretch ;)

Second

SEL9 has EAL4+ certification with the CAPP


Thrid

RHEL 5 will be going for EAL4+ certification with the CAPP, LSPP and RBAC

Fourth,

http://informationweek.com did do a pretty bad job of patching this news bit together


Last but not least, get your news from the horses mouth

http://www.trustedcs.com/news/6news6_1_1z.htm

;-)

jlc

Reply Score: 1

hm
by Anonymous on Wed 28th Sep 2005 14:56 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

we should see more of non nsa funded stuff like www.rsbac.org www.adamantix.org

Reply Score: 0

RE:[1]
by Anonymous on Wed 28th Sep 2005 17:05 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

we should see more of non nsa funded stuff like www.rsbac.org www.adamantix.org

I agree,i would like to add www.grsecurity.net and pax.grsecurity.net
I doubt EAL alone is enough.There should be a penetration certificate also.Features such as advanced encrypting,digital keys,etc add some points to the overal EAL certification but don't prevent a cracker from compromising the server.

Trusted Solaris might be a tough nut to crack but is exorbitant expensive.

Reply Score: 0

Very Cool
by Nex6 on Wed 28th Sep 2005 17:41 UTC
Nex6
Member since:
2005-07-06

I think this kind of stuff for Linux, is very cool. and is promising for for Linux in general.

Would be great Linux, made its way more into goverment and military systems.

-Nex6
-nex6.blogspot.com

Reply Score: 1

Secure systems
by Nex6 on Wed 28th Sep 2005 17:53 UTC
Nex6
Member since:
2005-07-06

this is A very good time , as all the apps that require
"EAL $ and above and or "trusted" status. can now be run on Linux, also means Companys and biz's alike can now get there hands on a "trusted" system for a reasonable price.

altho the Certifcation will be on IBM hardware, which I belive (not sure off) to run a "trusted" app you need to run it on the hardware it was certified on i think, which is good for IBM. ;)

but, many many comapnys can now get the benifit of a full EAL4_ trusted system for there apps if the need it.

cool



-Nex6
-nex6.blogspot.com

Reply Score: 1