Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 16th Feb 2009 02:38 UTC
PDAs, Cellphones, Wireless This week at Mobile World Congress Microsoft will release a free technology preview of Microsoft Recite. Microsoft Recite runs on Windows Mobile 6.0 or higher and allows the user to record voice notes and then store, search and retrieve information from them by simply speaking a word that they want to search for.
Order by: Score:
Wow
by robojerk on Mon 16th Feb 2009 06:30 UTC
robojerk
Member since:
2006-01-10

Microsoft being innovative?

That's unpossible!

Seriously, sounds interesting. Still though, I wish some other company besides Apple or Microsoft would take the lead position in the new cell phone market.

Android would at least allow other phone companies to collaborate together. I want to see what Nokia is doing with Qt/Symbian. RIM

Reply Score: 2

ahem
by l3v1 on Mon 16th Feb 2009 07:15 UTC
l3v1
Member since:
2005-07-06

This service collects information on a weekly basis about your use of the service as well as the version of the service that you are using and sends that information to Microsoft. Also, Microsoft will notify you when a new version is available. You may incur carrier charges when this information is sent between your device and Microsoft.


When they do this on a PC, I'd maybe agree to it. But when it costs money (to clarify: I pay for traffic on my mobile, not a flat rate), I have to say no.

Who tried it could say a few words about its practicality.

Edit: It sends all the recordings to their servers for processing and search, right ?

Edited 2009-02-16 07:17 UTC

Reply Score: 1

RE: ahem
by Morin on Mon 16th Feb 2009 09:15 UTC in reply to "ahem"
Morin Member since:
2005-12-31

Since the user gains no advantage of MS collecting data, this basically means that MS wants the users to pay for MS's data traffic. Nice try, but no thanks.

Edited 2009-02-16 09:15 UTC

Reply Score: 2

RE: ahem
by Pelly on Mon 16th Feb 2009 14:06 UTC in reply to "ahem"
Pelly Member since:
2005-07-07

If you have a data-capable mobile device and don't have a data plan, simply call your cell carrier and make sure data service is disabled.

If MS Recite attempts to phone home, it simply won't report back with the capability disabled at the carrier end. If your carrier states they can't block it, that's probably incorrect. Simply wait a few minutes and call back to get another person.

Most people with data plans have 'unlimited' plans so it's not going to be an issue.

Since MS Recite does have a desktop installer, those who wish to try it can, with no data charges.

Reply Score: 2

RE[2]: ahem
by ssa2204 on Mon 16th Feb 2009 15:00 UTC in reply to "RE: ahem"
ssa2204 Member since:
2006-04-22

If you have a data-capable mobile device and don't have a data plan, simply call your cell carrier and make sure data service is disabled.


Funny you should say that. When I went to get my HTC, that has wifi, I asked to have data service (3G) disabled. They said it could not be done. Then last October I had mysteriously somehow downloaded in one evening $170+ through AT&T. Funny, because the evening in question, I don't remember ever touching my phone. After calling to complain, then I was told after the fact I could have the service disabled.

Reply Score: 2

It works...
by TBPrince on Mon 16th Feb 2009 14:43 UTC
TBPrince
Member since:
2005-07-06

I tested it and it works very well, even for non-English languages. Very interesting and innovative though it's a bit annoying that you cannot operate by touching screen, for example to delete single items.

Other than that, it's a wonderful technology for smartphone and Pocket PCs. I expect that final version will be more polished, with a little bit more functionalities but anyway it's something making ur device a lot friendlier.

Reply Score: 3

Still
by mmu_man on Mon 16th Feb 2009 18:32 UTC
mmu_man
Member since:
2006-09-30

Why would one need to implement it online ?
The only reason is to tie people to it.
Dictaphones have long been one of the possible use of PDAs, it only adds pattern recognition using some FFT convolution. This can as well be done totally offline using mp3 files as storage. You'd just sync them with your desktop.

Still, I can foresee some issues with that...

- "darling, what did I tell you to buy this morning ?"
- "let's see" (to the pc) "shopping"
- (pc) "Result 1: 'do the shopping, buy eggs, salad, milk'; Result 2: 'After shopping, call Linda to plan the weekend'"
- "Linda ? Who's this Linda ? I thought you were going fishing this week-end!!!???"

Reply Score: 2

ready for real world
by Oszomby on Mon 16th Feb 2009 18:56 UTC
Oszomby
Member since:
2008-07-04

The question is how well will Recite work in a real world setting, with more than just 5 phrases to search though. How well will it function 6 month from now, after you’ve accumulated dozens of movie suggestions, driving directions, shopping reminders and what not. That should be well over a 1000 memos. How long will it then take to do the search, how many results will it come up with, how many of those results will be relevant?
Recite is a good idea. But turning good idea into an actual working product is another story. Microsoft’s history shows that it’s the latter part that they have problems with. There was never a shortage of good ideas: many of them were freely available and Microsoft didn’t even have to innovate. They just couldn’t implement those ideas right. At least not on the first few attempts. Personally, I wouldn’t expect anything useful till Recite7.0 or something is out.

Edited 2009-02-16 19:09 UTC

Reply Score: 2

Google anyone?
by melgross on Mon 16th Feb 2009 21:12 UTC
melgross
Member since:
2005-08-12

Sounds like a more basic version of the Google app on my iPhone.

MS is again second. I wonder if it will work as well?

Edited 2009-02-16 21:13 UTC

Reply Score: 0

RE: Google anyone?
by iain.dalton on Tue 17th Feb 2009 03:52 UTC in reply to "Google anyone?"
iain.dalton Member since:
2006-02-28

Google makes an iPhone app that lets you search through voice memos?

Reply Score: 1